
By: Ann Nocenti (story), Cliff Richards (pencils), Rebeca Buchman, Juan Castro, Le Beau Underwood, Phyllis Novin (inks), Pete Pantazis (colors)
The Story: The Dagger Clan try to prove that the size of one’s sword really doesn’t matter.
The Review: I always find it a little risky when a creator mentions how he was inspired by this-or-that or so-and-so in his latest project. Most of the time, he’s referring to some seminal work of the past, which is now held up as a standard for all works to follow. Not that this is his intention, but why invite that comparison? It just raises fans’ expectations and skeptics’ eyebrows that much higher, and a story tends to suffer in the process.
In nearly every interview I’ve read of Nocenti talking about Katana, she’s referred to Seven Samurai as a source of inspiration. I find this rather amusing because not only does the substance of this series bear no resemblance to that legendary film (except, perhaps, for Katana being a samurai—sort of), but nothing in the tone nor the structure of Katana evokes the spirit that made Seven Samurai special. This title already suffers from its own shortcomings; it can only look even worse when beheld next to a masterpiece.
For one thing, Samurai had a straightforward plot which served as an accessible backdrop to some meaningful themes. Whatever’s happening in Katana is none too straightforward and has little meaning you can get on board with. That she wants to take revenge on the Sword Clan is all well and good, but she lacks focus in her vendetta, which is incredibly disappointing for an ostensibly master assassin and samurai. She’s already confronted two figureheads with the clan, revealing her presence and intent to them with seemingly no other purpose. She claims to have “turned” Thrust to her side (which I still don’t buy, being one of the more poorly executed scenes last issue), but has no plan in mind to use him. And here, she seems inclined to abandon her mission altogether, as she contemplates joining the clan then takes the night to purposely fall into the Dagger Clan’s trap.
In this last act, Katana reveals her major character flaw, the one that’ll affect her prospects of long-term likability: pure arrogance. Now, pride in a character is no fictional sin, so long as they’re appealing in other ways. Katana clearly hasn’t got to that point yet. So when she decides to walk into the Daggers’ trap, reasoning, “If their skill is as pathetic as that obvious tripwire, I’ll count heads as I cripple sword arms,” you’re kind of glad to see her screw up and get her comeuppance. For someone who can’t even get a good hit off a noisy drunk, she really has no right to look down on anyone. It’s not a great thing to root against a hero in her own book.
But I do wonder if Nocenti ever originally planned to have this excursion with the Dagger Clan, who are really just a proxy to get Katana and Killer Croc in the same place, which in turn is just a set-up for the big “WTF” moment in the issue: not just the breaking of her sword, but—spoiler alert—the revelation that the Creeper has been contained within all along. Admittedly, the moment is startling, though not exactly in a good way. Nocenti never laid a bit of foundation for this twist, so it comes completely out of left field, and it also begs the question of how the Creeper’s origins will be completely revised in this incarnation.
Alex Sanchez may have his flaws as an artist, but at least his work is distinctive and frequently striking. Richards’ art is just plain and a bit boring to look at. It’s utterly conventional, only occasionally getting some extra life when Katana’s in action, which runs at odds with Nocenti’s offbeat story about urban samurai. He also misses little details in the script; as Katana makes her way to the Daggers’ hideout at the ship graveyard, she says she smears mud on her mask to dull its reflection, but when we next see her, there’s no mud to be seen. Pantazis’ colors are fine, but as unremarkable as Richards’ art.
Conclusion: Had this series remotely resembled any of Akira Kurosawa’s works, it’d be more enjoyable than it is. Instead, it’s all Nocenti with her trademark confusion and looseness, with some forgettable art attached.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I think Nocenti would have been better off naming the Sword Clan members in Japanese. “Coil” and “Sickle” sound okay, but “Thrust” just sounds dirty and wrong, and all would have been improved with actually foreign-sounding names.
Grade
Conclusion