
By: Geoff Johns & Richard Donner (story), Adam Kubert (art), Dave Stewart (colors)
The Story: Superman is relieved to find his biological clock satisfied at last.
The Review: I’ve expressed a fairly cynical view of Free Comic Book Day before, and sadly, every year I’ve been given no reason to change my mind. I suppose I’ll always have my doubts that anyone running a business for profit would actually ever dole out a free product with no caveats attached. DC’s offering last year ended up being a rather premature tease for the upcoming Trinity War nonsense, so it was pretty much worth what you paid for it.
At least last year they went through the effort of giving you original material with some superstar art attached. Apparently, when there’s no money to be had in it, the buck stops just before original. This year you get a reprint of the first issue of Superman: Last Son, one of the more notable arcs which ran in Action Comics over six years ago. Without going into the quality of the story itself, I view DC’s decision with a great deal of disdain.
It’s not lost on me that this is merely the prelude to a massive Superman push ahead of Man of Steel’s cinematic premiere. I just don’t understand why DC wouldn’t use the opportunity to show off the character as he stands in current continuity, as a way of indicating to the reader that there are great stories still to come from the icon. Dredging stuff from the past indicates a lack of confidence in the work being done with him now.
And if they are going to dredge up old stories, why would they choose this one? If I recall correctly, Last Son was well-received when it ran the first time around, but it wasn’t exactly a barnburner of a hit. (I won’t bother with spoiler alerts since this information is about seven years old.) At best, its impact was to introduce a potentially game-changing character, only to end up chickening out and relegating him largely to limbo status (except for a brief stint as Nightwing during Superman’s time on New Krypton, after which he literally went back to limbo).
You can easily get on board with Chris Kent, the adopted son of Superman and Lois Lane, as a concept. The question, of course, is what to do with him once the introductory arc is over. Most writers already have a hard time keeping Supergirl and Superboy relevant, and a Kryptonian child officially under the Man of Steel’s wing would only threaten their own places in the Super-family, possibly rendering both of them (and Chris himself, for that matter) redundant. Little wonder, then, that at the end of this arc, Johns-Donner neatly shunt Chris away, allowing Superman and everyone else to comfortably move on as if he never existed at all.
Besides the dubious quality of the story itself, you again have to question whether this story is really the most appropriate choice if DC’s hoping for a gateway comic to the rest of the Superman universe. I’m pretty sure any new readers DC might entice will be baffled to read this issue, only to find out that currently, Superman is not in fact married to Lois Lane nor even dating her; he’s not really a mentor to sweater-vest wearing Jimmy Olsen; both his parents are dead; and he no longer wears his underpants outside his outfit.
And then there’s the matter of the art. Now, I’m not exactly a Jim Lee fan, but I can’t deny that there’s a tight, polished look to his work that’s instantly attractive and appealing. I wonder what readers will think when they see the contrast between the ultra-slick, young dynamo of a Superman on the cover and the old-school, somewhat campy and middle-aged version who appears in the issue itself. Overall, though, Kubert does a good job. It’s not his fault that his Superman looks about ten years older than he’s supposed to be.
Conclusion: This is not only phoning it in on the most basic level possible, it’s not even a halfhearted attempt to phone it in with some kind of effort.
Grade: D+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – With that pixie haircut, Lois was halfway to soccer momhood anyway.
– I do think it’s kind of sweet that even in a sterile lab environment, Chris gets treated to juice boxes and a racecar bed.
Grade
Conclusion