BATMAN #20

By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Danny Miki (inks), FCO Plascencia (colors), Comicraft (letters)

Back-up by: James Tynion IV (writer), Alex Maleev (art), Nathan Fairbairn (colors), Dezi Sienty (letters)

The Story: Batman versus Clayface.

Review (with very minor SPOILERS): Last issue suffered from misaligned reader expectations.  Snyder & Capullo had been telling epic Bat-stories for a year and a half, so when they hit us with a mere Batman vs. Clayface 2-issue story, it was hard to know what to make of it: “Really?  Just a superhero fighting a supervillain?  No redefinition of what it means to be Batman?  No deconstruction?”  Now that last issue altered my expectations, it was possible to enjoy the solid execution in this issue.

From a macro-standpoint, it’s probably wise for Snyder to mix up the storytelling.  As mentioned above, he’s been telling hardcore Bat-stories for a long time.  Even before this partnership with Greg Capullo, he did that great run in Detective Comics.  Starting with next issue, he’s doing this Batman: Zero Year story that will run for 11 issues and will surely have epic overtones.  Maybe Snyder just thought we needed a cigarette break before going back into the serious Bat-stories.

Getting back to the qualities of this issue, it’s just good superhero comics.  It has Batman being clever and beating his foe.  It has people from the extended Bat-family in peril.  It fiddles with Batman’s secret identity.  And since we all love Bat-technology, it features TWO new Bat-suits.  Yay!  Batman FTW!

I guess lots of comics could claim to possess these elements, but the execution in this issue is what sets it apart.  Snyder just writes better than most guys.  With most mid-tier comics, I’m honestly a little unimpressed.  It isn’t that the writers “stink”, but I’m not sure they’re better writers than the top quartile of comic bloggers.  However, with Snyder’s dialogue, I’m always thinking, “Gosh, I just can’t make sentences that sound that nice.”  He’s really gifted.

One final aside about the story before we move onto the art (my GOD the art):  was anyone else knocked off stride when Clayface manifested as Joker?  Is there any remote possibility that Clayface was involved in the Death of the Family storyline?  For another matter, he also manifested as Damian–could he have been involved in THAT story?  I seriously wonder if Snyder is going to start using Clayface more.  Many of his stories are about how Batman/Bruce doesn’t know as much about his city/enemies/family as he thinks he knows, and Clayface could be a useful tool in those sorts of stories.  Maybe this isn’t as much of a disposable superhero story as it first seems?

Okay, now let’s talk about this art.  Holy crap is it nice looking!  Can you imagine anyone else drawing such a good panel of Bruce Wayne being vomited into a trash-compactor?  Long-time fans of Capullo know that he can draw the HELL out of some grotesque monsters, so I wonder if Snyder came across some old issues of Spawn or Haunt and said, “Whoa!  We could do a kickass Clayface story!”  OR I wonder if Capullo said, “Scott, you know that I can draw blobby monsters really well, right?  Why don’t we do a Clayface story?”  Regardless, when you see Capullo’s Clayface, you realize that you don’t want to see the old versions ever again (where it looks like a man who fell into a Super Sloppy Double Dare mud pit).  Of course, everything else in the issue is just delectable.  I’m so glad that Batman has pushed Capullo to superstar artist status because he’s deserved it for a LONG time.  I’m seriously trying to think of something he doesn’t draw well…

Even the back-up in this issue finished nicely.  I’m not sure it is “important”, but it was nice to get a Batman/Superman story…..especially since I’m not reading any other DC comics.

Conclusion: Really, really good.  This is how a “hero vs. villain” story should be: Get in, do your business for 2 issues and move on.  GLORIOUS artwork by Capullo.

Grade: A

– Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion