
By: Ann Nocenti (story), Alex Sanchez (art), Art Thibert (inks), Matt Yackey (colors)
The Story: No use crying over broken swords, Katana. Don’t try huddling in a heap, either.
The Review: Have you ever read a comic and halfway through thought to yourself, I can write a better issue than this? Yeah, me too. It’s an inherently arrogant sort of thought, we can all agree; after all, we are basically throwing down with writers who are actually getting paid to have their work published—not to mention the fact that we just put down our own good money to purchase this product we’re now disparaging.
I don’t want to overstate my own writing abilities here, but I’m pretty sure if I had Katana on my plate, I could at least deliver a coherent, focused plot. Nocenti, on the other hand, is all over the place. There’s really very little excuse for that kind of distraction in this case; it’s not as if she’s obliged to tie in the title to any event or story arc going on elsewhere. Yet these four issues have given us four rather different conflicts which have only the most tangential connection to each other and which Nocenti barely manages to develop before moving on to the next one.
We started the series with a very simple mission for Katana: exact revenge on the clan that took her husband’s life. Even on this point, she can’t seem to keep her plan straight long enough to get any work done. First, she makes a direct confrontation; then she enlists the aid of Thrust as her inside man; then she tries the covert infiltration, only to reveal herself and make a direct confrontation again; and then she considers joining the clan anyway. Despite having access to her inner thoughts, it’s impossible to tell what she’s thinking through all this.
Now, all of a sudden, that whole vendetta has gotten hijacked by a whole new, even bigger challenge, one she brought upon herself. You still have no idea what possessed her to go after the Dagger Clan when she, by her own admission, didn’t even have a handle on the Sword folks just yet, and all it leads to is the breakage of her only trademark, the only thing even remotely giving her an advantage over the other heroes and villains of the DCU.
Ordinarily, this would be a huge moment in her story, but Nocenti’s timing is way off. She has never managed to convince us that Tatsu is particularly good at what she does to begin with; she’s been defeated, blindsided, and shown up almost more often than she’s eked out any kind of victory. Frankly, the Soultaker never seemed like it gave her that much of an edge in any battle. So what impact are we really supposed to get over its destruction?
Finally, and most critically, Katana simply hasn’t come close to earning her weight as a solo star. In both her ensemble titles, she’s an interesting, but hardly adored member. Here, we’ve seen little to make her any more attractive or accessible a character. Her arrogance hasn’t been blunted by any sort of charm or charisma; it’s only made us root against her, in some ways. It’s no help that Nocenti doesn’t have the most consistent grasp of Katana’s voice.*
Besides these fundamental problems, I have a litany of other flaws and peeves I can get into: the aggravating recap of events in the issue’s front matter, characters talking aloud to themselves (“How does a hammer look at a nail? As something to pound. I have a shard of Katana’s special sword. Now to find something to cut.”), Katana’s inane questions (You shattered my Soultaker, Killer Croc. Why?”), Junko’s know-it-all attitude, the attachment of the Creeper and Killer Croc, etc. Unfortunately, the space of one review is not enough to go through them all in depth; just know they are there, adding their own burdens to the issue.
As interesting and distinctive as Sanchez’s art can be, it’s also inconsistent and distracting. He doesn’t always make the best choice of posture and pose for the characters. So often we have to look at their backsides or the bottom half of their faces, and even when we get a clear view of them, Sanchez doesn’t always draw them with regular features. Even now, I don’t have a good idea of what Tatsu really looks like; Madam Yoko is more recognizable to me than our lead. Yackey’s colors are fine, but have a tendency to blend together, giving little vitality to the page.
Conclusion: Katana’s a hard sell to begin with, and to impose such weak creative quality to the character will only damage her in the long term. It’s a problem when she gets better material in her ensemble work than her own solo series. Usually, I give a title one arc before Dropping, but since I don’t even have much of an idea where one arc begins or ends on this series, given its aimless plotting, I’ll just make it easy on myself and Drop now.
Grade: D+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * For example, no matter how fluent Tatsu’s gotten at English, the idea that she’d ever say, “Yup,” or “Yeah, good luck with that,” or anything else so colloquial just doesn’t sound right.
– Here’s one interesting detail: Shun’s body is tattooed with “the history of the Outsiders,” a connection to the Outsiders Katana’s JLA teammate has to deal with in Green Arrow.
Grade
Conclusion