
By: Kevin Eastman, Bobby Curnow, Tom Waltz (story), Mateus Santolouco (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)
The Story: Raphael doesn’t really have a calm center; it’s more of an angry center.
The Review: As someone who grew up with the cartoon TMNT, which was highly diverting even if not exactly the most sophisticated form of entertainment, it constantly surprises me how hard the comic book tries to make itself as credible as possible. True, they’re not exactly Byronic in terms of complexity, but they’re certainly more multifaceted and intelligent than the characters you saw on TV.
TMNT hasn’t entirely lost its whimsical nature; when your premise is a bunch of oversized reptiles trained in the martial arts, you can never eliminate every bit of the fantastic from the story. In the back of your mind, there always lurks a thought of how incredibly ridiculous all this is. Here, however, Eastman-Curnow-Waltz manage to keep that thought at bay, by bringing in a little more real-world authenticity than the Turtles are used to having: a willingness to swear, to shed blood, to more deeply embrace their Asian culture.
At the same time, there are now greater stakes and more fiercely individual personalities to the Turtles, proving that their growth isn’t just superficial. As this issue demonstrates, their internal tension is stronger than ever, with the rigid Leo and temperamental Raphael generating most of their conflict, leaving their mellower brothers and sternly gentle father to maintain the peace. Unfortunately, Splinter’s counsel, wise as it is, fails to address directly the failings of his two most aggressive sons, leading to their downfall here.
This is no longer a series where the Turtles can afford to let their character traits reach cartoonish levels. Their enemies have grown too canny and too determined to let such vulnerabilities slide. In an earlier age, Shredder might have fallen for the Turtles’ amphibious assault, turning into a mockery of himself as a result. Now, as if to demonstrate that he is long past the point of joking around, he goes through some violent lengths to challenge his opponents’ weaknesses.
Just as Krang’s invasion of Neutrino is no longer simply a mad power play, there’s no buffoonish grudge behind Shredder’s attacks on the Turtles and their extended family. He doesn’t want simply to get rid of them; his goals are more nuanced than that. Now that he finds himself the head of effectively an underworld criminal gang (albeit a highly trained and professional one), he no longer has the cache and respect that his clan once had in a long ago period. He must struggle for power and at the same time avoid authorities. To him, the Turtles are a highly irritating distraction, but also a potentially useful resource in his contention against other criminals. The interesting question is what combination of Kitsune magic and devious manipulation it will take to leverage the Turtles—or at least one Turtle—in that way.
Artistically, my dream for this series has come true. I don’t know if anyone within the IDW hierarchy reads this blog,* but someone must have been turned on to the same conclusion I made on the Secret History of the Foot Clan mini: Santolouco’s art and the Turtles go together like any stereotypical combination of foods. You can now tell the Turtles apart, a feat whose importance and impressiveness should not be underestimated. Somehow, Santolouco is able to make them look more human, credible, competent, and dangerous, but simultaneously let their personalities shine boldly through. Given such good material to work with, Pattison’s intensely vivid colors give the series an energetic feeling that feels intense, not just hyperactive.
Conclusion: With this issue, the Turtles take one confident step into being more than just a cartoon given the gritty treatment, but a completely serious series that operates on its own terms, strange as they are.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Probably not, honestly, because if you have any kind of wisdom as a writer, you’ll want to avoid most online critics, who are the most notoriously unreliable form of analysis ever—except for us here on WCBR, of course!
– Mikey’s reading an issue of After the Fire, another Tom Waltz series (which I have not read). I appreciate the subtle bit of plugging there.
Grade
Conclusion