
By: Too many to list—IMDB it.
The Story: The shocking secret behind Superman’s beard.
The Review: This is a very precarious point in DC’s quest for broad appeal. Marvel has established a very specific style for all its movies, one that audiences can easily love: a combination of spectacular action and credible character work. DC’s recent film projects have been anything but consistent. On the high end of the spectrum you have Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy, with so much thematic value as to nearly be considered important. On the low end, you have Green Lantern, which attempts and fails to emulate the Marvel style of superhero movie, confusing sex and angst for wit and drama.
Man of Steel clearly follows in the Nolan tradition and thus signals the kind of DC movies to come: striving for sophistication without losing any of that superhero action. In the latter respect, it succeeds extremely well. Whether it’s evoking fantastic settings, like the liquid-metallic world of Krypton, or simply bombarding you with one thrilling, CGI-laden scene after another, the special effects on this film are worth every expensive penny of its budget. Even in 2D, they are worthy of gasps and the occasional “Woah!”
The film also manages to combine several different cinematic genres into one, but more importantly, make them work in tandem with each other. I certainly didn’t expect Man of Steel to have such a strong feeling of extraterrestrial paranoia, and yet it suits the context of the story and gives the plot a threatening chill. Of all the superhero movies from both sides, this one probably has the biggest stakes. The alien invasion in The Avengers was so chaotic and localized that you didn’t really grasp what a risk it posed to the world. In contrast, the devastation in Man of Steel is enormous; it really does seem like the end of the world, lending even greater grandeur and glory to Superman’s feats.
As for the movie’s attempts to tell a serious, brooding story…well, it definitely gets points for trying, but like so many of these superhero movies that want to have “a message,” it fails largely from heavy-handedness. The messianic overtones are almost over the top, both in its symbolism (e.g., Clark illuminated by stained glass of Christ in a church, his near-crucified posture as he falls out of Zod’s spaceship towards Earth) and its expression. It’s not as grating as the constant harping on “fear” in Green Lantern, but it does lavish a disproportionate amount of time on Jor-El and Jonathan Kent to lecture their son on his embodiment of hope.
And really, the movie could have spent its time more wisely on other, more interesting points. The contrast of Krypton as a stifled, rigidly ordered society versus the promise of available choices on Earth should have been played more—especially if they wanted to sell Zod’s monologue of loathing at the film’s climax. Clark’s feelings of alienation certainly could have more resolution, and the development of his morality is mostly taken for granted.
Still, Man of Steel makes many unexpected choices which take you aback at first, but gradually make perfect sense upon reflection. Lois Lane’s early discovery of Clark’s identity may expose how straightforward, in the right circumstances, it would be to find him.* At the same time it enhances both her journalistic integrity and humanity and offers extra insurance that he maintain his privacy once he finally embraces his Daily Planet persona. Jonathan Kent’s controversial “Maybe” diminishes his infallible morality, but reveals a deep, fearful love and attachment to his son as well as a prudent understanding of humanity’s faults that Jor-El, a foreigner, underestimates.
And—major spoiler alert—the moment that may prove the most polarizing of all (certainly it got the biggest reaction from the audience by far) may be the one that best displays Superman’s character. Yes, his killing of Zod is shocking, but the script earns it a very credible way. Here you have Superman facing an opponent who cannot be negotiated with nor simply defeated, one who is determined to exact harm wherever he can. Even so, Superman tries to avoid the drastic, begging outright multiple times for Zod to stop. When it’s over, his expression of anguish is heartbreaking, and when he takes comfort from Lois, burying his head against her waist while on his knees—well, I think it’s brilliant that this shows him at his most human, vulnerable, and genuine.
I would be remiss in failing to mention what a stellar cast Man of Steel has. Everyone embodies their roles to a tee, especially the quartet of Henry Cavill (who by his figure alone is guaranteed to be this generation’s default vision of Superman), Amy Adams, Russell Crowe, and Michael Shannon. This is the case, even if the screenplay misuses their characters or doesn’t do enough with them. That makes it even more of a shame that the film trades character moments, opportunities for real interaction, banter, and empathy, for more action. Although the characters tend to speak the script’s agenda rather than really respond to each other’s personalities, their delivery elevates the actual performance to a respectable degree.
Conclusion: As a sort of Batman Begins for the Superman franchise, Man of Steel is an appropriate and respectable first outing for what is sure to be a financially successful trilogy, although it fails to be the classic that it could easily have been with better scripting and less spectacle.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Especially once he mentions that he’s from Kansas—to a military officer, if you can believe it.
– I did love that most of the people in the audience waited for the end credits for a special cut scene, only to have the lights flicker back on. That was a very satisfying collective, “Aww…”
Grade
Conclusion