G.I. JOE #5

By: Fred Van Lente (writer), Steve Kurth (pencils), Allen Martinez, Marc Deering and Juan Castro (inks), Joana LaFuente (colors), Chris Mowry (letters)

The Story: A small GI Joe team has to fight its way out of an American town that has been completely flipped by Cobra.

Review (with minor SPOILERS): “Pretty good story undone by poor art!”  THAT is the headline for this issue.

It’s never a good sign when an issue credits three inkers.  The art on this series hits new lows in this issue.  The problem is mostly related to depth.  If you stare at a lot of the panels, a crazy “magic eye” thing will happen.  Suddenly characters’ arms and legs will appear to be in totally different planes than the rest of their bodies.  It’s screwed up.  And once you start to see these problems with depth, the anatomy of the characters starts to come undone too because your mind starts trying to rationalize how an arm/leg could bend to achieve these weird depth positions.  Steve Kurth has never been my favorite penciller, but it’s not fair to heap this on him.  Depth problems are generally the fault of inkers and colorists.

The overall artistic style also has some challenges.  I generally like a cartoony style (think Humberto Ramos on Spider-Man) and I think cartoony styles tend to be more forgiving of slight non-adherence to conventional human anatomy.  However, this issue shows that you still have to get your basic depth and forms correct or the cartoony style isn’t going to save you.  Worse, it can sometimes suggest things that aren’t intended like odd body movements and weird facial expressions.  I heard a comic artist (Dave Wachter) speaking on a podcast recently and he was talking about how comic art has the power to suggest things that actually aren’t drawn on the page.  He was talking about this in terms of how he had grown as an artist when he stopped trying to draw objects/people precisely and started learning how to use his art to suggest things that he could never draw accurately.  Wachter is a great artist and can use that sneaky art-trick to make great comics.  Unfortunately, the guys on this comic use that power for ill.  I guarantee you will see all sorts of weirdness that probably wasn’t intended by the art team if you stare that the panels enough.

This issue is just a hot mess from an art standpoint.  IDW really needs to get it together with the two main GI Joe books.  The Cobra book with art by Antonio Fuso is fine, but the main Joe books have looked pretty bad for several years now.  It’s almost like IDW is trolling us or trying to get Hasbro to terminate their contract or something.

It’s a shame too, because the story is pretty sharp.  As with most of these licensed properties from IDW, the story is probably better than it really needs to be.  Selling GI Joe comics isn’t rocket science as you’re appealing to a fanboy nostalgia.  As such, the comics probably need to be merely “serviceable”.  What’s great is that Fred Van Lente is trying to make it something more.  I really like the whole structure of this first story-arc and how an entire American town has flipped over to Cobra.  On the surface, you might think that is preposterous; Americans are patriotic, after all.  But when you consider all the angst in American politics from both the right (Tea Party) and left (Occupy _____) where both groups think that the United States has gone horribly wrong; add in all the wiretapping and Facebook spying; and then, as Van Lente’s Baroness points out, 24% of Americans think that President Obama is a foreigner, 76% think JFK was killed by the CIA, 57% think there was a conspiracy around 9-11 and 46% think the entire universe was created in 144 hours.   Take all of that and you really can create a fictional, dark-mirror version of American where a town turns on it’s heroes.  It’s really clever.  GI Joe doesn’t need to offer social commentary; the series works just fine if Joe and Cobra are fighting in some far-flung location.  Kudos to Van Lente for trying to do MORE.

It’s just a darn shame that the art lets him down.

Conclusion: The story is great, the art is bad.

Grade: C

– Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion