THE WAKE #2

By: Scott Snyder (story), Sean Murphy (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)

The Story: How uncomfortable to realize the beasts you’ve got caged are your own relatives.

The Review: We humans have gotten so comfortable in the position of being the only high-intelligent species in the world (and, as far as we know, in the universe) that the very possibility of having to share that position with something else makes us nervous even when it fascinates us.  Almost all science-fiction nowadays takes that conceit for granted, but the reality of it would be, I think, a much more frightening scenario.

What would it be like, for example, to look into the eyes of a creature we believed mindless, only for us to realize that it’s analyzing us as much as we are them?  What would be our reaction if we made this discovery while the creature was in chains, after we had knocked it up a little—or a lot?  I imagine we’d all break out into a flop sweat, hoping that the thing doesn’t have buddies that it can touch base with.  After the events of this issue, that’s exactly what Lee and her companions should be hoping for right now.

The situation with these mermen Lee has encountered is even eerier because they’re not just aliens, nor some strange species that managed to develop intelligence behind our backs.  As Lee posits (and as the issue’s prologue confirms), these creatures are our evolutionary cousins.  Even if Snyder relies on some crackpot hypotheses for his premise, the scientific evidence he offers is credible, thus convincing, thus horrifying, and the implications are only more so.

For if “the water is where we became human,” but we humans left the water for higher and drier places, then what effect would staying in the water have on our ancestors after five million years?  It won’t just be the superficial changes, the gills and the fins and the tail and so forth (although the size of the creatures—nearly twice that of the average man—does strike you with a certain awe).  Lee notes that some believe it’s our sea diet which gave us our intellect in the first place; for all our thinking power now, it may be merely a shadow of what might have been.

It might not just be a matter of knowledge and inventiveness, either.  Snyder didn’t just have Dr. Marin, our lore-master, make his observations about the relationship between these creatures and legends of mythical sirens for no reason.  Remember: the sirens reputedly had the power to induce hallucinations in men, to lure them with subconscious desires.  If we set aside the magic of myth for science, what does that say about these creatures’ abilities?  And if their abilities are such that they can convince a man he’s speaking to his wife, then we’re dealing with some perceptive beings indeed.

We know, too, from the submerged vision of the future world that this “first” encounter won’t end with man and merman embracing in recognition of their common ancestry.  Take this incident along with the revelations Agent Cruz makes about Lee’s past work with the government (“A defense project” called S-Net, the side-effects of which include “animals with their brains leaking out of their eyes,”), then it seems like we’ve made a very bad impression on our relatives indeed.

Snyder’s script is full of foreboding already, and Murphy’s art only makes it seem even more ominous, as he fills panels with inky shadows that, like the water, seemingly threaten to engulf and drown you.  His understated style is what really sells the horror of our sea creatures.  In most circumstances, mermen (and certainly “aquatic apes”) would look kind of comical and almost cheesy, but Murphy’s sophisticated, sleek lines smooth those tendencies away, and Hollingsworth’s mild colors do the rest.

Conclusion: Certainly engrossing, though not completely free from predictability, craftily written and subtly drawn.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – I’m hoping that Brenner is dead, because I don’t know if he could go through life knowing he passionately made out with a sea monster.

– I was thinking to myself you can’t have a team of explorers without the one borderline psychotic guy, and Leonard Meeker fits that bill pretty well.

Grade

Conclusion