HAWKEYE #11

By: Matt Fraction (story), David Aja (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)

The Story: If, by “It’s a dog’s life,” you mean an awesome one, then yes, you are correct.

The Review: In the great cats-versus-dogs debate, I must admit I fall on Team Canine every time.  Not that I don’t like cats; I do.  I do appreciate their cleverness and independence, even though they always leave me with the feeling that if I died, they’d have no qualms about feeding on my corpse.  But the loyalty of dogs, their boundless, abiding, tail-wagging affection, touches me more than all the keyboard-walking and belly-rub-encouraging antics of felines ever could.

So it was pretty much guaranteed that I would be deeply, helplessly taken by an issue of Hawkeye starring his faithful companion, Lucky.  More than being told simply from his perspective, the story does away entirely with any other narrator, even omniscient ones, leaving us completely within Lucky’s interior.  Although his view of the world is more simplified than his owner’s, with dialogue reduced to random words and phrases and knowledge limited to what can be seen and smelled, Lucky has his own ingenious, valuable system of analysis.

That comes through most clearly in his olfactory perceptions, which are rich, detailed, and informative, almost to the point of being telepathic.  As he strolls through his apartment building, sniffing what there is to be sniffed, he transmits to us a stream of intel about his fellow residents, giving effective briefs of their lives beyond Hawkeye.  Lucky’s smelled observations form the building blocks which we can use to construct an engaging, substantive story.

This is not to say Lucky is merely a cipher for our deductive powers.  He picks up an unknown scent which sparks the beginning of his own detective story, where he plays the scarred gumshoe in a murder mystery.  All the elements of your classic crime-pulp is here: the petite, fair, beautiful dame; the dirty work of scavenging the streets to find clues; the rough and bloody tumble with thugs and criminals.  Along the way, Lucky falls in love,* finds the murderer, and even engages in a tense rooftop standoff.

Granted, his discovery process doesn’t lead to much new information for us, although we do find an important connection between the Bro gang and one of Hawkeye’s tenants, and the appearance of a homeless bum who smells like Clint signals another big mystery to come.  It’s also true that for those who haven’t followed the series, the significance of many plot points and deductions in the issue would be completely lost on them.  Your appreciation of the issue thus increases exponentially to your knowledge of prior events.  Still, even for those who come into the issue with no background information whatsoever can enjoy how wonderfully complex and layered a story about a simple dog can be, which parallels how compelling the adventures of the most ordinary member of the Avengers can be.

In some ways, I see this issue as more of a standout for what art can be in mainstream comics than for writing.  Aja has always shown outstanding creativity in the way he conveys information, relying simultaneously on architectural, design, and symbolic principles to add unheard of dimensions to what you see on the page.  Dealing with a script where text is almost removed from the plot encourages Aja to new heights of inventiveness, and every page is sort of a revelation (or should be) on how a comic book story can be told.  By reducing the exposition to a schools of pictographs, Aja challenges us to become more engaged with his work, applying the maximum of our thought to interpreting what we see.  Hollingsworth’s limited palette of colors gives good tone to Aja’s figures, but also affords no distractions from what’s visually important.

Conclusion: Certainly something of a breakthrough in storytelling for this medium, although purely in terms of substance, it depends too much on a reader’s familiarity with the ongoing plot to be effective.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Although, honestly, I was kind of creeped out at first because I was so sure that the smaller dog was a puppy, making Lucky something of a canine child molester.

– Lord help me—Lucky’s salute to Clint may be the best thing Marvel has done all year.

Grade

Conclusion