By: Geoff Johns (story), Brett Booth (pencils), Norm Rapmund (inks), Andrew Dalhouse (colors)
The Story: The JLA reveals that breaking up evil robots as an early specialty.
The Review: A long time ago, when Identity Crisis was still a controversial novelty, I remember one of the better jokes in the series involved a bunch of villains sitting around their satellite HQ and discussing the death of Donna Troy. I believe it was Merlyn who deadpanned, “She’ll be back.” The line reveals that comic book writers know how meaningless death in the superhero genre is, and yet the cycles of lifelessness and resurrections continue.
I’ve given up hoping that publishers will take a hardline stance on this point. All I ask is for writers, if they’re going to use death as a narrative gimmick, then to at least use it well. I’ll be more specific and say that they probably shouldn’t end an issue on a death if they know that we know it won’t take for longer than a single issue. Here, Catwoman’s “death” doesn’t even last even three pages after her shooting, and we all know, before Martian Manhunter reveals himself, how that managed to come to pass.
This bothers me not so much because of the event itself, which makes absolute sense within context of the story, but because of the thought process behind its execution. Johns must have known no one would for a second believe Selina had really died. The fact that her own ongoing series doesn’t reflect it makes that conclusion immediately clear. Yet he still thought he could get some kind of extra reaction from us by using her death as a cliffhanger last issue and as a point of tension here (see the falsely sentimental cover of JLA hands lain on a coffin).
Even setting that aside, the issue suffers from equally problematic defects. For an anchor series like JLA, it seems incredible how underwhelming the action has been during this initial run. Half the fun of a team book is seeing the diversity of the members’ power sets, coordinating them in unexpected, clever combinations, but the closest we get is Katana slicing into robot-Sasquatch’s fur for Hawkman to peel it away. Even worse, the Secret Society, whom we’re supposed to take as an enemy to reckon with, prove worryingly weak, practically crumpling against the JLA’s rudimentary teamwork.
Other long-running problems persist. Johns still struggles with writing more than two or three characters at a time very convincingly, which is a problem for a large ensemble cast, obviously. Here, only Stargirl and Simon Baz sound free and unforced; everyone else either resorts to factory-made lines (“I have heard enough. More than enough—from you.”) or avoids speaking at all. Johns also remains clumsy with his exposition, inserting it into the most awkward places, like Ivo explaining how the Society manor transports itself around.
Booth’s art does little to nothing to improve matters. His art, though obviously energetic and most effective during moments of action, makes the title look juvenile, which it can ill afford to do. The characters ultra-narrow faces contort almost comically to render their exaggerated expressions, and his storytelling often feels like there’s little thought behind it at all. Some panels lack any impact at all and many feel disconnected from their neighbors; rarely does the action in one panel flow naturally to the next.
There’s no solace to be found in Matt Kindt’s back-up either, which is one long, droning series of expositional chunks. There’s just barely enough time in a back-up feature to tell a self-contained scene, rather yet a whole story, and Kindt’s attempt to introduce a whole new character, his back-story, and his connection to Martian Manhunter ultimately fails due to the format alone. It’s simply improbable to develop a sympathy for a character within such a few pages, especially when there’s still so much you don’t understand about him. Mauel Garcia’s art (inked by Robin Riggs and colored by Wil Quintana) is fine, but falls within DC’s serviceable, but plain-Jane house art style.
Conclusion: Mostly, the story and art (in both features) are just functional. There’s not a single spark of originality and hardly even an attempt at it, which bodes very badly for such a major series.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Out of curiosity, I decided to look up how much blood a person can safely lose before dying, and it’s, setting aside various other factors, 3 to 4 pints. Since a quart is equal to 2 pints, that means Hawkman is still within the safe zone.
– It sounds like Stargirl still has S.T.R.I.P.E.S. as her sidekick—hooray! At least there’s that to look forward to.
– Seems like it’s starting to be a trend for DC villains to be reimagined as heroes first: what with both Dr. Light and Chronos as A.R.G.U.S. agents.
Grade
Conclusion