TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES #23

By: Too many to list—check out the review.

The Story: For those who’ve ever wondered what turtles dream about.

The Review: A while back, a friend of mine and I had a long discussion about predictability in fiction.  He insisted that predictability is toxic to the quality of any kind of story; if something is predictable, then it reveals not only a lack of originality, but also weakness in execution.  I saw his point, but ultimately disagreed with the basic premise.  After all, predictability is a very relative thing, dependent on every individual’s fictional experience.

As a reviewer, I’ve seen more than my share of narrative formulas, but who’s to say anyone else has had that luxury?  From last issue’s final scenes, I already knew that this month would be all about Shredder pressing Leonardo into his service.  And because Leo, as the most devoted of Splinter’s sons, could never be legitimately persuaded to follow Shredder, I knew that the only avenue to obtaining his loyalty would be some serious Kitsune magic.

But even I couldn’t have predicted what a disappointingly one-sided process Leo’s whole psychic breakdown would be.  Since he lacks enough lucidity to even recognize Shredder, then it really takes little effort to sway him to the other side.  In a way, it makes the sequence even more tragic, because his reality is so defined by the villains that he can’t tell what’s real.  However, it also makes his conversion a bit of a farce, since it requires almost no moral or internal struggle on his part.  Essentially, Shredder and Kitsune never have to actually justify their ideology because they can freely break down Splinter’s using no logic whatsoever.  You’re pretty sure, for example, that Splinter would never make as broad a statement as, “[Y]ou do not kill, ever.”

The most potentially interesting bit that comes out of the Foot Clan activity is a hint of tension between Shredder and Kitsune, a sign that at some point, their ambitions must diverge.  Seeing Leo in their grasp, Kitsune crows, “Our ultimate destiny is within reach, Saiki.  I promise.”

“My destiny, Kitsune,” he corrects her.

“Ah…just so, my lord, just so.”  But there’s an obvious insincerity to her response that makes you think she’s the one holding all of fortune’s cards here.  Keep in mind, her existence and work predates Shredder’s by some time.

In contrast to the simmering friction over in the enemy camp, the bonds among the Turtle family are stronger than ever, what with Leo’s kidnapping and Casey’s dire injuries.  In fact, the family seems to keep growing, now that Angel has been brought to the fold.  There’s a sweetness in the simple, straightforward way she explains her relationship to Casey and her deep respect for him, especially because Kevin Eastman, Bobby Curnow, and Tom Waltz wisely underplay the romantic overtones where most other writers would have pushed it.  It’s a good sign, too, that they use Casey’s situation as an opportunity to add some new complications to his personal storyline, instead of simply removing his participation from the story altogether.

If there’s an essential warmth to this series, it’s probably because the people behind it have so much of it themselves.  Why else would you have all of TMNT’s former artists come back to make their contribution to the issue?  Each gets a couple pages to show off his individual style, and while some are highlights (Ben Bates, Dan Duncan, Ross Campbell) compared to others (Kevin Eastman, Andy Kuhn), they all pale next to Mateus Santolouco’s truly brilliant work.  Prior artists have made the Turtles look credible; Mateus makes them look good enough to stand next to any of the big pop titles.  Ronda Pattison has her work cut out for her, trying to give each artist an appropriate palette while maintaining a consistent look for the issue overall, but she manages very well.  Santolouco may be a star, but Pattison is the rock of this series.

Conclusion: Another solid effort from all involved, although the issue takes a few liberties in getting where it needs to go, undermining the credibility of some of the characters in the process.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – I’m sorry, but I couldn’t help laughing at the panel where an oversized Shredder in modern ninja gear tenderly cradles Leonardo in his arms.  It’s pretty hilarious.

– At least that doctor’s going to be fairly renowned for his expertise in treating ninja-inflicted wounds.

Grade

Conclusion