GREEN LANTERN #22

By: Robert Venditti (story), Billy Tan (pencils), Rob Hunter & Jon Sibal (inks), Alex Sinclair & Tony Avina (colors)

The Story: The orange monster becomes the green-eyed monster.

The Review: I miss Sinestro.  I know that’s a rather odd thing to say on this title, but the more I read Venditti’s Green Lantern, the more I realize why Geoff Johns kept Sinestro around for so long when the title relaunched.  While Sinestro in himself is a thoroughly compelling figure, one of the best characters Johns has ever reinterpreted, I think we’ve overlooked the importance he had as a foil to Hal Jordan.  In many ways, Hal is only half himself without his frenemy.

So long as you had Sinestro throwing his arrogance and insensitivity around, Hal always seemed much more sympathetic by comparison.  Sinestro’s flaws minimized Hal’s and humanized him as a result.  Now that we don’t have Sinestroy playing bad cop, Hal has to kind of take on that role himself, especially in his leadership position.  Granted, we find him in the middle of a crisis and no one’s at their best in such circumstances, but that doesn’t make him seem any less a jerk when he berates a gaggle of clearly terrified, unwilling recruits for doing nothing in the face of Larfleeze’s attack: “Are you four just going to stand there—or are you going to fight?”

Really, though, this is the least of Venditti’s missteps on this title.  Far more problematic is his habit of tossing in characters from out of nowhere, beginning with Larfleeze last issue and continuing with the sudden arrival of Saint Walker and a random Star Sapphire here.  None of this would be a problem if Venditti used them to some purpose.  Instead, all prove outstandingly useless in their appearances.

The whole Larfleeze invasion in particular feels poorly conceived as a threat.  Larfleeze is just so inherently comedic in his tunnel-visioned greed that his antics in this issue come across like a bad recurring villain from a children’s cartoon.  Hal and the Corps basically send him on his merry way using a trick so obvious that Hal might as well have winked as he pulled it off (“You know,” he insists to the oblivious Kilowog, “the treasure.  The treasure!”).  When Larfleeze finally departs, he screams, “You won’t keep me from your stuff forever!” in a way that reminds you of Gargamel screaming, “I hate those Smurfs!”

At least Larfleeze gets a chance to make some kind of impression on us.  Other characters aren’t so lucky, like the aforementioned Star Sapphire, who appears nameless and dies nameless, about four pages later.  We get no introduction to her, no explanation as to why she’s with Saint Walker when he arrives, absolutely no reason to care about her whatsoever.  In fact, Venditti seems to have written her in solely to kill her off, sending her ring to another.  Not that we care any more about Nol-Anj, ex-GLC prisoner, or her doomed romance with GLC Warden Cossite (who also dies).  Readers of Demon Knights know Venditti likes to move fast in his storytelling, but now he’s decided to skip essential steps in both character and plot development.

Tan provides more than adequate art, especially once it’s well-inked and vibrantly colored by Sinclair and Avina (that scene of all of the confiscated ships on Oa powering up for takeoff is awesome).  In many ways, Tan looks like the artistic transition between Yildiray Cinar and Nicola Scott, more detailed and dynamic than Cinar, but not quite as bold and focused as Scott.  At any rate, he assures that the art will be the least of Green Lantern’s problems, even if it never reaches the cinematic grandness of his predecessor.

Conclusion: Overall, an oddly silly plot with a lot of unearned moments.  Only the art gives you little to complain about.

Grade: C-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Why would a Star Sapphire need to pilot a ship to get anywhere?  Didn’t she learn the lesson Abin Sur did when he decided to play it safe with conserving his ring energy?

Grade

Conclusion