• Categories

  • Archives

  • Top 10 Most Read

Thanos Rising #4 – Review

By: Jason Aaron(story), Simone Bianchi/Riccardo Pieruccini (art), Ive Svorcina (colors)

The Review: I’ve read a lot of negative commentary about Marvel’s “serious” reimagining and back-story creation for Thanos, but I love it.  A big purple planet-eating Hamlet is just what I need during the long, hazy days of summer.

The Shakespearean melodrama of this series is quite evident. Seconds after giving birth to him, Thanos’ mother (Sui-San) attempts infanticide but is stopped by her husband. Because of his unique mutation, Thanos grows up brilliant but socially isolated, constantly searching for that which will bring his life meaning. He discovers murder and ensures his destiny as a monster through matricide, a crime he commits attempting to discover and remove that element of his mother that created the monster in the first place. Heavy stuff.

On the cover of this issue, Thanos’ stance and body language remind us of the countless actors that have portrayed Hamlet and contemplated the skull of Yorick unearthed by the gravediggers in Act 5, Scene 1.  Thanos is a melancholy “prince” who, having failed to discover his fate on his home planet of Titan, searches the universe for the meaning to his life, leaving a trail of broken females, fatherless children and dead planets in his wake.  He has rejected science and art and love and has embraced the only thing that seems to make sense to him – death. After destroying yet another nameless civilization, Thanos gazes out across the annihilation that he has wrought and asks “When did mass murder become so very…dull?’  He reassures one of his victims that the murder of his family and the destruction of his world was nothing personal, saying “If it’s any consolation, I chose this world purely at random. I bore no grudge against you or your people. The deaths of your family meant absolutely nothing to me.”

Thanos believes love compels him to kill, but the woman for whom he kills is a phantom, witnessed only by him and with whom he regularly converses and by whom he is sexually frustrated.  He is called “Thanos the Destroyer” but the men that serve on his crew secretly refer to him as “Thanos the Mad”. Discovering that his muse is actually Death, Thanos contemplates suicide by incinerating himself and thinks “One step. One step was all it would take”. In other words, “to be or not to be.”  Thanos elects life for himself, Death for himself and death to everyone else. Thanos has become Death’s avatar and his first stop is the place where it all started, his home world of Titan.

Contemplating his son’s reputation as a destroyer of worlds, Thanos’ father (A’lars) discusses his course of action with the ghost of his own father, just as Hamlet did in four different acts in the play.  The ghost warns A’lars to begin preparations because Thanos is returning and he must be ready to finish the job that his mother had started; i.e. kill his son.  A’lars is reluctant to believe the truth about his son and in doing so probably seals his fate, the fate of the population of Titan and the fate of half the universe.

The artwork is beautiful. Thanos appears powerful and oppressive, the galactic landscape is alien but familiar and the colors are muted and rich. The expressions of all the characters, even the weirdest aliens, are evocative and recognizable. The story is interestingly laid out through a combination of smart conversation panels and full page-bursting action.

Marvel is taking a huge gamble in featuring Thanos as the villain in the next Avengers movie because they will almost assuredly screw it up. Earlier renditions of Thanos have portrayed him as a clown and incompetent despite possessing the most powerful weapon in the galaxy; the Infinity Gauntlet.  Jason Aaron’s interpretation on Thanos elevates the character to an intense and tragi-serious position and I don’t think there is ANY way that this wonderfully nuanced character can realistically be portrayed in a $250 million Memorial Day weekend blockbuster.

Conclusion: Highly refined and multilayered origin for a very important Marvel villain. The pathos and melodrama may be a bit much for some readers.

Grade: B+

-Gerry O’Malley

About these ads

3 Responses

  1. While I do like your approach to the story, which is another take on that series that is as valid as mine was in my earlier review, I’d have to disagree on your assessment of just who is Thanos.

    Thanos, for a long time, was someone who was clearly able and willing to obtain immense power, yet always failed at the mst important moment. As it had been written by Jim Starlin in one of the key series featuring the character, the reason why he always fail is that he basically hates himself and see himself as unworthy.

    His constant search for validation from Death and his failure in actually receiving any affection from the entity is part of the cycle the character is stuck in, which makes it why Thanos will never actually win. He does not actually believe he can and thus, despite all of his intellect, his planning and his great feats, he just cannot catch a break.

    It was that mix of basic psychological and relatable problem mixed with the huge cosmic setup that made Thanos such an interesting character to me in series such as Thanos Quest, The Rebirth of Thanos and Infinity Gauntlet and I’m not exactly seeing anything quite like that in this series.

    However, like I said earlier, this is pretty much my take on the series, which may be biased I suppose, but it’s just not doing it for me.

    • I appreciate your thoughts and a lot of what you believe is, I think, coming across in this series. Thanos is still power-hungry and angry and as a famous psychologist once said, all anger derives from fear. I’m sure Thanos doesn’t understand (yet) where his anger comes from (probably his fear of failure of incompetence or his misunderstanding of his own mental illness). Either way, I’m enjoying Aaron’s execution and this version of Thanos’ origin.

      • What I didn’t really like from this version comes from the fact that Thanos, in the three issues that I did read, came off as being a puppet of fate and Death, as if nothing here was actually his fault. It was fated to be and so it looks almost like we have to pity this being who will become a genocidal maniac because he has been pushed by forces outside his control into becoming so.

        A lot of what has been written here do make a lot of sense when you compare to what will happen later in his life, yet it was this specific aspect that really drove me away from this version. Mayhaps they actually fix it in this issue, but the three issues I did read gave me a version of Thanos that I did not really care for.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 791 other followers

%d bloggers like this: