By: Jeff Lemire (story), Mikel Janin (art), Jeromy Cox (colors)

The Story: What the Justice Leagues need are fewer magicians and more mediators.

The Review: I haven’t had the greatest experience with Justice League Dark, a series which I’ve already had the displeasure of Dropping twice during its relatively young life.  Peter Milligan’s initial run was confusing, melodramatic, and horribly repetitive, and while Lemire and Ray Fawkes were an improvement, they never managed to execute their ideas in any way that didn’t feel generic.  In short, JLD has never lived up to its edgy promises—not even close.

So it is against my will that I find myself picking up yet another issue of this series, which makes me suspect that Trinity War isn’t an inspired storyline so much as an overeager marketing tool for the Justice League brand.  Don’t take my word for it, though; as you read through this issue, it becomes clearer that Lemire is working on this Event with only half a heart.  Like an underpaid stripper, beneath all the flash and glam, the story’s simply going through the motions.

It all starts with the appearance of the Phantom Stranger, whose presence, as usual, signals danger, though on no certain terms.  Instead, he relies on overblown statements delivered with the crack of doom (“I have walked the earth for centuries and seen great darkness, but there has never been a threat greater than this!”), which somehow convince both Batman and Steve Trevor to act.  This, despite the fact that Stranger offers exactly zero specifics as to how Wonder Woman and the JLD finding Pandora will be “the death of all”; that Batman has only Zatanna’s uncertain voucher of the Stranger to go on; and that Steve acknowledges the danger Pandora’s Box poses, yet never considers that it might not be a good idea to leave such a relic out on the loose with an entity of unknown motivations.

And here I’d been hoping to avoid another poorly set-up confrontation between superheroes.  The ridiculous thing about the whole scenario is that they all—Diana, Batman, and Steve—have the same goal: figure out what’s going on with Superman and save him.  By all accounts, Diana has a very rational, if impulsive, course of action in mind, which makes Batman and Steve’s resistance even harder to understand.  And what does it get them?  The defection of more than half their respective teams, a lot of unnecessary animosity, and Constantine secretly stealing away with Shazam for his own ends.

Meanwhile, Superman, at the encouragement of the Question, takes his fate into his own hands.  For someone who was so convinced of his own guilt last issue, he makes a shockingly quick turnaround here, now convinced that “something’s been done to me.”  If that’s the case, then it makes even less sense that he would decide to AWOL from A.R.G.U.S., which only destroys his credibility as a paragon of virtue.  The annoying thing is that there’s a very simple compromise that would please all parties: leave Superman at A.R.G.U.S. while the non-murdering Leaguers investigate the Question’s lead.  Having him break out and force the loyalty of his teammates just seems unnecessary and silly.

But perhaps the biggest flaw of this series is the fact that Lemire (and Geoff Johns) hasn’t given you a reason to care about the story’s events.  Phantom Stranger completely fails to specify what kind of “terror” awaits if Batman and Steve fail to stop Wonder Woman’s band of rogue Leaguers.  And although most everyone rejects the very possibility of letting Superman die, all this hero-worship* seems quite unfounded, since we’ve never actually seen his influence on them (and in the context of this young universe, it’s still too early for Superman to have the global cache that his previous incarnation had).

Janin is talented, and he can draw some pretty imagery, but they all seem so static, an antithesis to the way superhero comics are supposed to capture motion.  For all of Janin’s mastery of proportion and anatomy, there’s no spark of life behind the visuals.  Look at the way Cyborg, Stranger, Zatanna, Batman, and Steve all take off running in nearly the exact same, Olympic-runner’s posture.  It doesn’t matter how well Janin draws their capes and coats rippling from motion; it still looks dull and frozen.  Cox’s colors are acceptable, though their flatness makes the characters look even more like soulless mannequins.

Conclusion: Generic to a fault, and so much of it feels pointless and unnecessary, thanks to a lot of poor decisions which make the characters seem petty, shortsighted, and gullible.

Grade: C-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Lemire really goes overboard in writing everyone’s protest of Superman’s innocence.  Firestorm: “And there is no way it was Superman’s fault.”  Green Arrow: “I mean, this is Superman we’re talking about here!”  Even Frankenstein gets on the bandwagon: “I have seen many warriors in my centuries upon this earth, but none as great as Superman.”

– If the Atom thinks she’s got a lot to feel guilty about, maybe she should walk in on Firestorm forging Kryptonite at the enemy team leader’s request.

Grade

Conclusion