By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: Can the best Korean BBQ redeem the worst dystopia?  Stay tuned and find out!

The Review: As a parallel-universe nut, I was very excited to see Miss America’s dimension-shattering powers the last time we were here.  The idea of a bunch of kids adventuring and wreaking havoc across the entire space-time continuum, Exiles-style, just sounds great, doesn’t it?  It’s the same way I felt about the Dial Bunch’s dimension-traipsing mission in the soon-to-be-axed Dial H: the possibilities for stories just become endless.

And just like with Dial H, I’m disappointed to see Gillen not taking advantage of these possibilities nearly as much as I’d hoped.  Certainly I didn’t expect him to start the issue with a major time jump, checking in with our scrappy gang after they’ve already experienced most of their interdimensional trials and tribulations.  “We’ve seen astounding sights that catch my breath and will haunt me for life,” Kate’s journal recounts.  “It’s awful for everyone…  Barely anyone’s sleeping, and when they do, what they dream of makes them wish they hadn’t.”  In essence, Gillen skims over much of what makes stories like this compelling.

Not that we don’t get a few fun glimpses into their travels: a parallel-New York with Korean barbeque that is the “absolute pinnacle across all realities,” apocalyptic worlds where gods have died and harpies bearing Kate’s face flock, a realm populated by cuddly green chibis that gather round the Y.A. with worshipful cries of, “Demiurge!”*  So Gillen has no shortage of ideas; he simply doesn’t explore them nearly as much as he should.

That’s not to say these brief dimensional stays don’t reveal hints for future conflicts that he can pick up later.  It’s not lost on the Y.A. that not-Patriot has led them to “[s]o many dimensions where we go bad,” though why he does so is a mystery.  Billy’s godlike presence in one universe in particular means that at some point, the extent and effects of Billy’s powers will have to be addressed.  And while Noh-Varr may be all gung-ho about Earth and its music now,* the fact that the team has encountered so many parallel-Earths conquered by the alien in the name of the Kree may indicate that he’ll have to confront his original purpose again sooner or later.

As for the story at hand, the Y.A. fail to catch up to not-Patriot and they also fail to discover his true plans or nature.  Clearly, he’s no ordinary being, given his ability to freely traverse the Marvel multiverse with apparently no effort (while even the punchy Miss America may get exhausted with her efforts) and his familiarity with other interdimensional beings.  He also knows more about them than they do him, or else he’d never known to bring Mother into it.  On the plus side, luring Mother back to her home dimension also means an opportunity to keep her there, allowing the Y.A. to return to their Earth homes without harassment.

Before the Y.A. can regroup, however, they run into another obstacle that throws their course off-kilter, one that fans of Gillen’s Journey Into Mystery will enjoy while the rest of us are left to wonder who or what is going on.  But one thing all of us can rear back in surprise on is the issue’s final page, a moment worthy of DC’s “WTF-certified” campaign.  Spoiler alert—now, I have no problem with Prodigy’s passionate lip-lock with Teddy in itself, but I find it a craven cry for attention instead of a legitimate character moment.  Gillen has neither developed any type of relationship or even interaction between the two young men at all, and last I heard, David had a serious crush on former Young X-Man Noriko.  It’s like Buffy’s Willow going lesbian all over again; we all have to appreciate the progressiveness of it while ignoring the fact that it makes no sense whatsoever.

McKelvie has a gift for rendering clean, precise linework that manages to avoid appearing completely static.  He provides just enough accuracy and variation in the characters’ posturing to make the art look animated, and although the subtlety with which he draws expressions is such that their thoughts are hard to read, it encourages you to put more effort in reading between their lines to speculate as to what they’re really thinking.  Wilson’s coloring is a marvel, with lighting so restrained and natural that it’s positively cinematic.  The New York of Earth-212 looks amazing as a result, with a warm glow that seems to radiate from its urban glory.

Conclusion: Skips over a bit too much material in its attempt to keep the plot on track, and delivers a poorly founded twist.  Otherwise, the script and art are as hip, cool, and entertaining as they’ve always been.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Demiurge refers to an ancient Greek concept of an “artisan-like figure responsible for the fashioning and maintenance of the physical universe.”  Which may explain Billy’s star-crafted face looming across the planet’s sky.

* I wouldn’t care to meet Gram Parsons, but running into Johnny Cash would be amazing.

Grade

Conclusion