By: Mark Waid (story), Paul Smith (art), Jordie Bellaire (colors)

The Story: East Coast mystery man meets West Coast daredevil.

The Review: What is it about pulp, specifically one era of pulp, that keeps readers coming back for more even decades past its prime?  If you ask me, pulp offers baggage-free entertainment: all the action and dramatic flair, without the challenging gray areas.  In a world where each piece of fiction is a different cocktail of increasingly wild combinations, pulp is the whiskey shot of genres: straight, to the point, and just what you needed.

Certainly, there has been no better age for the everyman character.  So many of our heroes nowadays have to be “special” in some way: a mutant, a prodigious intellect, a person touched by the hand of fate—someone who is different from everybody else.  The Spirit and Rocketeer are comparatively ordinary beneath their domino mask and space helmet.  Denny Colt and Cliff Secord aren’t brawny Adonis’ or super-geniuses or gifted with unusual abilities and powers of any kind.  They get by on their guts, a good dose of cleverness, and their values.

If our two heroes are real men’s men, then their girlfriends are real men’s women, in the most chauvinistic sense of the term.  It doesn’t surprise me that pulp had about as much success with women back then as it does today.  Even if the flesh-and-blood ladies of the time were inundated with the same demeaning nonsense as Betty here (“You’re young and beautiful and charming—but incomplete!  You need to find a man!  Yes!  Keep sticking that lip out until you find a man!”), I imagine they didn’t appreciate the words coming from a man’s pen.  It’s a good thing Waid has the excuse of writing a period piece, or else he’d have an angry mob of women to face.

In a weird way, too, Betty and Ellen have better defined personalities than their beaus in this first issue, even if they’re not necessarily attractive ones.  Each falls on one side of the stereotypical dichotomy of female characters: Betty is the man-killing seductress (one look at the Spirit and she has compunction feigning a swoon into his arms: “Oh, my!  Why, I can…I can barely stand, I’m so overwrought…someone catch me!  Someone strong…and handsome…and dreamy!”); Ellen is the stuck-up nag who fails to see the forest for the trees (“Where’s the Hollywood Bowl?  Did we fly all that way to race around the sticks?”).*  By contrast, Denny and Cliff sound quite alike in their good-humored haplessness.

Even if Waid relies mainly on classical pulp archetypes to do it, he does render strong portrayals of our cast, particularly the supporting characters.  You can practically hear Dolan’s crusty rumble (“Auggh, my back!  I’m never flying across the country again, no, sir!  You hear that, Ellen?  We live here now!”) or the virtuous Alderman Cunningham’s ringing baritone (“We were elected to serve the public good, for mercy’s sake—not to line the pockets of business magnates!”).  With any luck, the acclaimed Daredevil writer can do with Denny and Cliff what he does with Matt Murdock.

There’s really little mystery to be had here.  The story is a typical whodunit; the motivation is greed and power; and the victim is a plain obstacle to those things.  Waid doesn’t even bother to disguise the villain’s identity (or one of them, at least).  The one compelling thread of the whole plot depends entirely on the low-tech world we’re dealing with: how one man’s murdered body can wind up on the other side of the country in less than eight hours.  Otherwise, there’s not much material to chew on.

Smith’s art is clean and full of charming that is just short of cartoony, perfect for a series so full of wholesome characters.  His eye for post-WWII aesthetics is spot-on, and there’s definitely a lot of energy to the way the characters move.  Somehow, he can convey the high-speed careening of Dolan’s driving or the Rocketeer’s jetpack better than many artists with more realistic styles.  The only disappointment is he lacks the sheer storytelling creativity that marks the Will Eisner style.  Bellaire’s colors are very well-done; even though she’s working with a period that almost exclusively favors browns, grays, and navy-blues, she still makes the issue pop as needed.

Conclusion: Some significant shortcomings in the character work and plotting, but otherwise an appropriate and entertaining tribute to the classic pulp era.

Grade: B

-Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * This is a far cry from the spunky, progressive, self-sufficient Ellen who appeared in David Hine’s The Spirit a couple years ago.

Grade

Conclusion