By: Ales Kot (story), Rick Leonardi (pencils), Andy Owens, Derek Fridolfs, Marc Deering (inks), Brad Anderson (colors)

The Story: Two teams of crazies, but only one will make it out with pie on their face.

The Review: All too soon, we’ve come to the end of Kot’s promising run on this series.  I still don’t really understand why this had to happen, though the continuously dwindling sales probably have something to do with it.  At any rate, my mind’s made up to depart from Suicide Squad at the same time Kot does.  In just four issues, Kot has definitely established a powerful, specific voice and direction for this title, which I don’t believe anyone can emulate.

There is a very, very fine line to the tone Kot has brought to the Squad, balancing precariously on a tightrope between extreme* and excess.  Take James Jr.’s attraction with Waller, for instance.  Despite how difficult it is to believe that a sociopath like him can experience something like sentiment for anything, James’ feelings are still convincing.  Of course, choosing Waller as his object of affection is simply inspired—no other word for it—but it’s the sinister curiosity behind James’ obsession with her that seems true to his character.

It’s a shame I won’t get to see more of how this clearly doomed relationship will turn out.  For one, I’d like to know how much Waller perceives James’ private regard for her and if her conversational petting is just her typically manipulative manner of securing his devotion and services.  I’d also like to see more of their mutual brainstorming, instead of using James as a convenient repository for all the exposition Waller has to offer.  You’re dealing with ostensible geniuses here, yet you often only get evidence of that after the fact.

Of course, their success largely depends on the unique talents of the team itself.  It’s their unpredictability and unflinching reactions to, well, pretty much everything which sets them apart from everyone else in the DCU.  Does it get any better than Harley slapsticking her opponent to death?  “Pick your weapon,” demands the insolent Crow Jane.

“Okay,” Harley says agreeably.  “I pick pie.  It’s buttermilk whisky.  Fancy a try?”

Enraged, Jane launches an attack: “Sonic scream!!!!”

Harley retaliates: “Landmine pie!!!!”

This would all be more impressive with more developed villains than we get.  It’s hard to tell if their flatness is a result of Kot having to unexpectedly wrap up his intended storyline; given Kot’s predilection for short arcs, he may very well have chosen to introduce and dispose of them all at once.  Either way, the minions stand no chance against the Squad, especially a Squad equipped with a sniper rifle, killer bees, weaponized pheromones.  It’s a shame, really.  We’re led to believe that Lynch is Waller’s strategic equal, but his counter-tactics prove unavailing against her at every turn, leaving him to go out with a whimper on top of a bang.

As if to rub a bit of salt into the wound of Kot’s departure, Zircher is off-issue for the occasion, leaving Leonardi as his sub-par replacement.  Although Leonardi’s cartoony style does sort of fit the occasional moment of slapstick in the issue, it almost steals the edge and bite of the script everywhere else.  Fortunately, Kot’s writing is solid enough that even the least impressive of DC’s house art can’t hurt it none, but it’s hardly a grand send-off for the writer, especially when Leonardi occasionally fails to draw what you’re clearly supposed to be seeing (i.e. Lamplight’s energy blast, Crow Jane’s sonic scream).

Conclusion: What a brief, bittersweet affair this has been.  It’s hardly the finale Kot intended or deserves, but even to the end (and even though Leonardi’s insipid art), he gives us glimpses of the greatness that might have been.  Dropped.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * One setting caption reads: “Some Country Somewhere Far Away.  The Office of General Dictator President God of Everything That Is Alive.”

– I do enjoy Kot’s semi-sarcastic captions: “The Unknown Soldier.  Is wearing a mask.”

Grade

Conclusion