By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: Between an angry ex-girlfriend and a sadistic interdimensional parasite, I choose parasite.

The Review: I’m not much of a clubber, but every now and then I can be convinced to slick my hair, put on the trendiest clothes I have (read: a single outfit picked out for me by a gal friend specifically for such occasions), and contort my body into what can generously be called an impression of dancing.  The clubs I’ve been to all turn out the same: splashy, colorful, sophisticated, and hip on the outside, loud, juvenile, and a little pointless on the inside.

Young Avengers is like the happening club in the Marvel U right now, down to the unexpected lip-locking.  While you’re drawn to its energy and adventurous spirit, after a while, you can’t help noticing that there’s really little actual adventure to it.  Gillen can throw the cast into as many foodie joints as he wants and consider it a job well done, but a comic book demands more than appeals to pop culture and the hipster zeitgeist.

For this arc, Gillen’s goal seems to be taking us away from the action just when it gets interesting.  Why else would he go through the trouble of plopping our heroes in the land before time, introducing them to Loki’s ex, then having them skedaddle without actually doing anything about it?  More importantly, why won’t she do anything about it?  For someone who seems pretty serious about getting revenge on the person who put her there, she doesn’t seem very interested in doing so when the opportunity is “crapping himself” in front of her.

The thing is, you have no doubt that somewhere in the back of Gillen’s mind there’s a master plan in store.  Leah’s appearance would seem like a total waste if it wasn’t for an important connection with a non-divine Young Avenger at the end of the issue, clearly signaling a more substantial role down the line.  Similarly, you can see the long-term impacts of a lot of bits given to us during this arc—the suggestion that Billy’s “going to rewrite the rules of magic,” Kate’s discovery of Noh-Varr’s first Earth girlfriend, Mother’s ominous but inscrutable declaration to Kate, “My side soon”—but none of these pan out into much excitement now.  Even our heroes’ gambit of dropping an army of their alt-universe selves upon Mother* is simply a momentary visual distraction for them to beat a hasty retreat.  Kate may be right when she says knowing “more than we did” is “better than nothing,” but you mostly share Billy’s disappointment about how little they’ve gotten out of these past two issues.

About the only scenes which bears any fruit in this issue are Teddy and David’s interactions in Mother’s home dimension.  I had my doubts as to whether Gillen could offer a good enough explanation for David’s sudden desire for the mans; even Teddy sees the weirdness of it (“Your Wiki page needs an update.”).  I’m not totally persuaded that David’s knowledge-explosion can actually alter his sexual preference,* but it’s a reasonable enough excuse and his connection with Teddy does set the shapeshifter on the road to his big relationship decision at the end.

No matter how underwhelming the script, we can always count on a visual treat from McKelvie-Norton, who render their superior art with as much “but of course” casualness as when Miss America kicks through dimensions.  No zany page/panel construction this time; just the usual, perfectly formed figures and significant visual details.  Anyone notice that despite an invasion of parallel Young Avengers, not one included a facsimile of Miss America?  I don’t know how Wilson can be so bold in his color choices, yet still keep them mild and classy, but he always does, which is a big part of what gives this title its gloss of sophistication.

Conclusion: For an arc that demanded our heroes to travel universes, encounter dimensional phenomena and ancient goddesses, and ask some hard questions about themselves, we get some very low-key results out of it, though plenty of food for later thought.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * That would open a whole new can of worms, it seems.  If he could absorb others’ sexual preferences, why wouldn’t he absorb other personality traits, like sadomasochism or a weakness for peanut butter and banana sandwiches?

* Good thing all those duplicates were evil, otherwise we just might have to confront the ethics of Y.A. selling out essentially themselves to the clutches of a hungry interdimensional parasite.

Grade

Conclusion