By: Marguerite Bennett (story), Ben Oliver & Cliff Richards (art), Daniel Brown (colors)

The Story: Once again, Lobo ruins the party spirit.

The Review: I know he’s got his fans, but for my part, I’ve never cared very much for Lobo, except for his li’l incarnation back in the Young Justice days.  Gratuitous violence has always made me feel every so queasy, nearly as much in fiction as it does in real life, and Lobo rarely did anything without excess.  With little in the way of self-reflection and the most mercenary motives, Lobo didn’t have much substance to offer as a character.

So what drew me to read a whole issue featuring the unkillable killer?  Well, if you must know, I hopped on mostly because out of extreme curiosity as to a woman’s approach to someone so oozing with machismo as Lobo.  I hoped that Bennett could offer a little more nuance to the Czarnian than we’re used to, if not as a female writer, then as Scott Snyder’s latest protégé.*  Maybe it’s misguided to expect Lobo to be anything other than what he is, but surely he has room for a little more dimension, no?

I’m not sure we quite get that in this one-shot special, though Bennett does take some steps towards that lofty goal.  While his new, slim and sleek appearance really does nothing for his character, one way or the other, on a visual level it does announce that this Lobo is not the ungainly tank he used to be.  He’s still dangerous, but true to his leaner frame, he relies less on brute strength and more on skill and precision, accomplishing the same grisly tasks as his prior incarnation a minimum of effort, noise, and blood.

But as he later reveals, this brisk style of murder is only one side of his character, the consummate professional.  He soon assures us that underneath his pompadoured exterior, he still retains that enormous capacity for violence he’s known for: “Rich…an’ warm…an’ bloody…”  Bennett’s obviously trying to find a middle ground that can appease diehard fans of the original Lobo, while still making him fresh and accessible to new readers.  It’s a tricky balance, but portraying him as surly rather than raucous may be key to making it work.

Bennett actually goes a bit further than that, however.  This new Lobo may have, of all things, a conscience, though an easily repressed, bare hint of one.  His reaction to discovering the actual cargo he must deliver certainly shows more gentleness than you’d expect (“It’s okay—get up, you’re safe—”), but before you can start mistaking him as an antihero, he firmly shows his true colors: “Get back in the cage.”  It’ll be interesting to see if his compassion can extend any further than a helping hand, particularly with a lower reward at stake.

In this case, Lobo has too much to lose to let a bunch of helpless hostages sway him from his course.  The revelation of an “imposter,” buffer, louder, and bearing his name does throw the longevity of this new Lobo into uncertainty.  Seems like there’d be too much temptation for DC down the line to write off their attempt to redefine the character as a failure and fall back on the old model.  Still, it’ll be interesting to see which one turns out to be the Main Man in the end.

Oliver’s photorealistic style has always seemed eerily frozen, more a series of perfectly posed and rendered stills than a moving story.  That’s very much the case here.  Rarely do you see Lobo in a sequence of movement; instead, the panels shift from one dynamic pose to another, with little to no transition in between.  Take a shot of Lobo putting a friendly arm around his target’s neck, a wine glass in one hand, which suddenly transforms into a double-splash of the target’s body already sliced to pieces as Lobo poses with a red-hot blade in either hand.  Each image looks great in itself—the whole issue is quite beautiful, even more so with Brown’s warm, solid colors—but they don’t quite mesh together the way good comic book art should.

Conclusion: There are suggestions that a greater revamp is at work with this oft-caricaturized icon, but this is not the revolution you’re looking for.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * As it turns out, the best way to make it in the comics business is to have Snyder as your professor.  Sounds easy to me!  Where and when can I register, and how soon before I get a call from Dan Didio?

Grade

Conclusion