
By: Jim McCann (story), Rodin Esquejo & Dan McDaid (art), Arif Prianto & Lee Loughridge (colors)
The Story: Like the Duracell Bunny, Elle keeps on going and going and going and going…
The Review: When this story began with Elle in the Garden, your natural inclination was to believe that someone put her there on purpose. But now that we’ve found out the true purpose of Jairus is to make her ripe for resurrection, all the creepy psychic powers she’s shown afterward appear to be an exciting bonus. In that case, we have, as I noted last issue, some new questions about how Elle’s out-of-body abilities will tie into the plan to make her immortal.
While you hope that McCann will reveal a more specific purpose for the Garden in time, right now it serves as the sole means for Elle to resist her mother and grandfather’s plans. If one thing has been made clear about Elle, she’s headstrong—literally and figuratively. The way she ended up in this state to begin with was a result of her determination not to let Min and Erik have everything go their way, and she carries that determination to an extreme at the end of the issue. It may not foil them completely, but it’s enough that she frustrate their masterwork.
Throwing wrenches may be enough to derail the whole operation because, as we see from Erik’s flashbacks, this is a very delicate goal he’s taken on, prone to disaster. In fact, it’s implied that the only reason he’s even gotten this far is because he got someone like Elle for his grandchild. We see that the results of his experiments have come to tragedy or nothing. It is only with Elle that success is unexpectedly, dramatically achieved, and it’s not entirely clear if Erik had anything to do with it. Obviously, Elle’s timing threw him off, not unlike as it’s doing now.
Another thing we learn from Erik’s past is that his life has been one of tragedies, yet persisting to hope in spite of it. I suppose McCann means for all this to blunt, if not justify, the “unpalatable” things Erik has done to his own bloodline, but mustering sympathy proves a little harder than you might think. With little exploration into Erik’s relationships with his father, brother, and wife before they come to their grim ends, you might feel a touch of pity for him, but only in a distant sort of way. If his band of brothers proves nothing else, he’s not the only one who’s suffered undeserved hardship, and actually it’s possible his obsession with beating death has brought some of it on him.
The evolution of Erik from well-intentioned man to man who’s killed his granddaughter repeatedly appears to be a slow, subtle shift in priorities. More dramatic is the sight of a young Min, newly married to Ed Peterssen Sr., smiling and with a seemingly normal capacity for affection in comparison to the coldhearted—let’s just say it like it is—bitch who threatens her own son. Even though this is all Erik’s plan, Min’s inexplicably frigid dedication to it, at the cost of her family’s stability and happiness, makes her out as the more obvious villain.
One look is all it takes to see how laughably and inappropriately cartoony McDaid’s art is; you don’t even need the contrast of Esquejo’s nearly photorealistic work for that. It just seems bizarre to me how this series places such a high emphasis on artistic realism most of the time, then for past sequences select artists with a largely exaggerated approach to figures. The only way I can explain it is that McDaid’s flat and simplistic art reflects the flat and simplistic way we tend to view our own pasts, but that’s a fairly big stretch.
Conclusion: A terrible slowdown in the plot, still well-executed by McCann’s storytelling prowess, but redundant, repetitive, and unaffecting in the information it provides. The involvement of McDaid and his silly-looking art also drags on the issue somewhat.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Don’t you love how the women have been the ballsiest characters on this series? If it were left up to Eddie, Miles, and Frank, they’d probably still be thinking of ways to hoodie their way to victory right now. Meanwhile, Dr. Gellar just resorts to body-snatching.
– Although, that said, her wife probably will have some objection to any theft of cadavers whatsoever.
Grade
Conclusion