By: Geoff Johns & Sterling Gates (story), Szymon Kudranski (art), John Kalisz (colors)

The Story: Whether for good or evil, every man can use an excellent butler.

The Review: You know the most disappointing thing about the Secret Society?  The fact that it’s been an incredible misnomer, for despite its brief existence, it hasn’t been much of a secret (as A.R.G.U.S. knew about it when the Society was Signalman and a bunch of robots) nor much of a society.  Ultimately, the Society was rendered moot the moment the Crime Syndicate entered our lives, and we haven’t had much reason to care about the group or its mastermind ever since.

Still, since the Outsider was ostensibly the man responsible for the state of Forever Evil, it made sense for Johns-Gates to at least dot their i’s and cross their t’s on this still largely mysterious figure.  So in a way, naming this issue Secret Society is something of a misnomer, too, since the villainous group features in only the most indirect way for all of a page.  To make up for it, Johns-Gates reveal that the Outsider may have a more crucial, lasting role in this Event than expected, making the issue more worthy of a read.

It also helps that Johns-Gates manage to write a fairly solid story about the Outsider’s Earth-3 origins, which are of course tied deeply to Owlman’s origins.  Along the way, they throw several twists along the way, some of them quite clever.  Making Earth-3’s Dick Grayson the Talon to Thomas Wayne’s Owlman is pure serendipity in continuity terms, and even more so once it’s revealed that the Thomas Wayne in question is the junior rather than senior.

As poetic as these details may be, they also confuse our understanding of Earth-3 and how it works.  Clearly, this is a more complicated world than simply the moral opposite of Earth-Prime.  In many ways, the characters retain the core sensibilities of their Prime counterparts: Owlman’s desire for control, Alfred’s loyalty to his master, the Joker’s desire to create chaos amidst Owlman’s rigid world order.  This is a far more textured portrait of the Earth-3 characters than you’d expect from the usually literal Johns (and, to a lesser degree, Gates).

These complications are especially present in the development of Owlman.  Being something of a fascist, a murderer, and a philanderer* apparently doesn’t mean that he’s incapable of feeling affection, regret, or even guilt.  It’s that last emotion which surprises us, even the Outsider, for one cannot feel guilt without a conscience, which means Owlman can’t be devoid of one.  Sure, his might be set on a reverse course than ours, but it’s clear, especially from the last page, that he strives no less to make things “right” than Batman.

All these secrets and mysteries being bandied about between Owlman and Outsider are very intriguing,* so much so that you wish Johns-Gates had given us more rather than a totally redundant and mechanical summation of what the Outsider got up to between the time he arrived on Earth-Prime and the time when the Syndicate exited Pandora’s Box.  Unfortunately, Johns-Gates don’t make even this summation worth our while, since it offers no new details on how the Outsider started his Society work and leveraged resources to make Forever Evil a reality.

Much as I enjoy Kudranski with bigger and brighter colors, I can’t deny that he delivers his loveliest work when the lighting and coloring are dim and he can delve in the shadows (and Kalisz is fantastically cooperative in both regards).  This gives an eerie edge to every expression and action, making every moment seem a little bit more profound than it really is.  The sequence of Alfred-3 succumbing to Joker’s laughing gas seems so helplessly painful that you actually manage to feel a kind of pity for the butler, even though he’s clearly the bad guy here.  That’s pretty decent character work from just the art alone.

Conclusion: Some rather sophisticated work from Johns-Gates, though perhaps not quite as informative as it should be.  Kudranski once again proves that he has no equal when it comes to drawing villains with both menace and sympathy.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Although Ultraman doesn’t have a lot of boundaries where ethics are concerned, I imagine that he draws a “Bro’s before ho’s” line much like anyone else.

* I’m particularly interested in what happened to Bruce-3 if his brother is the one who rose up to take on a costumed identity.

Grade

Conclusion