By: Too many to list—or even to review.  Just check out the issue.

The Story: Will you catch any of these folks speaking with the devil?

The Review: These Vertigo showcases are proof positive that there really are an endless number of ways to look at the world, or even just one thing in it.  Both Ghosts and Time Warp offered stories that dealt with actual spirits and time-travel, but just as many stories that explored spirits and time as concepts, and a few that struck at the subjects on both a literal and figurative level.  It’s pretty amazing to see what the imagination will dream up when prompted.

Take Brett Lewis’ “Mars to Stay,” which in both substance and form resembles less like anything having to do with witches and more like a hard piece of science-fiction—the hardest kind, given how Lewis doesn’t take too many liberties with the fiction to deliver science that actually falls within the realm of possibility, if you have a cynical view of the way people work.  Maybe that’s where the witchcraft lies, in the slow, creeping way that the stranded crew’s psyches break down, as if infected with a curse.  Either way, it’s an impactful, haunting tale, despite having no clear connection to magical women whatsoever (and it doesn’t hurt that you get Cliff Chiang’s starkly sharp art illustrating the whole thing).

In fact, most of the features in this issue have only the most tangential connection to witches or the supernatural, revolving more around pressing social issues instead.  Annie Mok’s “This Witch’s Work” and Ales Kot’s “Little Witch” both fall into this vein.  Their stories have a political dimension and emotional integrity that stand very well on their own, with only a few passing references to the issue’s theme: the “Witch Pills” in the transgendered Reina’s medicine cabinet, the nickname of the Afghani girl befriended by one U.S. soldier who agonizes over leaving her behind.  Even when your classically supernatural witches figure heavily in the story, their importance lies mainly in how they spur self-discovery for other characters: the closeted old man in Steve Beach’s “Daniel” who encounters his old flame through a séance; the Cape Town residents in Lauren Beukes’ “Birdie” who receive scraps from the local bird-whisperer that turn out to be profound mementos from their forgotten pasts.

Even a story like Matthew Sturges’ “Fellow Travelers,” where you have a woman with a pointy hat and broomstick, ends up being about something else altogether.  By inverting the Salem witch trials with the McCarthy era of Communist hunts, Sturges makes a statement about persecution in general—not a very profound one, admittedly, but at least it comes at the end of a rather entertaining reversal.

In this entire issue, only two features can be classified as traditional witch stories.  “Legs”, by Kelly Sue DeConnick, is the more modern of the two, revealing bits and pieces of a larger, more personal narrative that never comes fully into the light.  What exactly is the connection between the spider that lives in Ellen’s brain and the apparent tensions between her mother and grandmother?  But at least “Legs” has more intrigue than Mariah Huehner’s “Rise”, which winds up being another one of these witch revenge stories, where a town suffers because of the prejudiced wrongs of its forbears.

Aside from one or two* features, nearly everything offered in this issue has a few strong points going for it, especially where the art is concerned.  Although time and space doesn’t afford me the chance to discuss the artistic contributions in detail, I want to make it clear that this is as impressive a collection of up-and-coming artists and visual veterans as it is a sampler of rising writers.  If anything tells you right away how seriously Vertigo takes these issues, it’s in their dedication to putting skilled and talented artists to work on them.

Conclusion: The best Vertigo anthology issue yet, teeming with stories and art that have all the finesse of the most practice witch’s craft.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * I just shake my head in bewilderment over the latest chapter of Toby Litt’s Dead Boy Detectives.  It makes better sense here than in Time Warp, but it’s still the least affecting piece in the whole issue—much as it was in the previous two Vertigo showcases.

Grade

Conclusion