
By: Robert Kirkman (writer), Charlie Adlard (pencils), Stefano Gaudiano (inks), Cliff Rathburn (gray tones), and Rus Wooton (letters)
The Story: The good guys finally team up to attack Negan!
The Review (with SPOILERS): Let me know when this comic is ready to do something… Not much really happens in this issue. It looks like something could happen for a second, but then we get another unlikely event (producing the mayor of Hilltop) that prevents anything serious from going down.
At this rate, would anyone be surprised if in the next issue someone comes up behind Rick and says, “I think you may have left the toaster on at your house.” And Rick will have to shout to Negan, “YOU STAY RIGHT THERE YOU SUNNOVABITCH!!!!! I HAVE TO GO BACK HOME TO CHECK ON SOMETHING!!!!! SO WE CAN’T FIGHT UNTIL NEXT ISSUE!!!”
There are several BIG problems creeping into The Walking Dead. One of the problems are these delayed payoffs to big storylines. TWD has always been a slow burn, but I don’t recall prior arcs actively trolling the readership in the same way as this Negan storyline. I mean, we’ve been hovering on the brink of war for over a year now. There have been several instances where it looked like a premature climax would surprise us, but nope! That was just a tease for one more issue. I guess that’s the problem… This doesn’t feel like a story slowly developing.
The other problem is that these characters and storylines have been going on for too long for traditional “slow-burn” to work. Bear with me while I relate an analogous experience. Back in the late 1990s, the Star Wars novel series launched this really ambitious storyline called the New Jedi Order. The concept was that extra-galactic aliens were invading the Star Wars galaxy, so the ex-Rebels and ex-Imperials had to stop snipping at each other and deal with a colossal new threat. It was a good concept, but the story stretched over 20 novels. I read them all, but somewhere around novel #12, I got bored reading the blow-by-blow of every lightsaber or X-Wing battle. More and more I started to think, “Just tell me who dies and move on. I don’t have time in my life for another four-page lightsaber duel.”
And that’s where I’m getting with TWD. We’re not really learning anything new about these characters. We’re just watching characters we KNOW go through events. The events need to be more rapid-fire. More editing is needed. I just don’t get it. It isn’t like the TWD story should ever have to stop. Kill a major character, relocate them to another area, put them on a boat, have some characters go away for 30 issues, find some new sort of post-zombie settlement where the government is really weird… There’s no reason to milk storylines this way.
Now, this issue isn’t totally devoid of interesting stuff. It doesn’t do enough with these storylines to merit a higher grade, but there is some decent clay to mold something interesting.
Carl is growing up: I’m curious to see what happens with Carl in this storyline. You can see how Charlie Adlard is starting to draw him more grown up. He’s at that age where he will have a growth spurt, and given the decline of “Western Civilization,” I’m reminded of those stories about how boys used to become “men” when they were 13-14 (as opposed to ~27 in today’s world). No other real comment on this except that I’m curious and paying attention.
Michonne’s romantic life: Kirkman has been fiddling with Michonne’s love life for a couple of years. She has successfully gone to bed with only black men in this zombie-ridden world. Tyreese, Morgan, and now Ezekiel… A few issues ago she groped at Heath. About the only black man in the comic that she hasn’t flirted with is the minister. And remember how a couple of years ago, there was some very subtle romantic tension between Michonne and Rick? I find this whole plotline to be interesting because I have no idea what Kirkman is up to. But he is up to something. It really isn’t like Kirkman to be subtle like this for years.
Ammo factory: It was nice to see Eugene again. Even if I think the ammo shortage is kinda stupid since the US government still has stockpiles of ammo from World War II. I still like Eugene and I’m glad he’s found something useful to do. I’d really like to see more of his potential relationship with Rosita. I honestly find that much more interesting than anything that comes out of Rick’s mouth.
Let’s also note that for the first time since issue #7, we have an art-change on TWD. I think this storyline is going to be bi-monthly, so they brought in Stefano Gaudiano to ink over Charlie Adlard’s pencils. I honestly didn’t notice this until I typed up the credits for this review, but then remembered that a few panels looked different. Not bad, just different… That’s going to happen when you have one artist drawing the series for so long. Everyone else just looks different. But it isn’t bad or distracting.
Conclusion: Man! This storyline needs to get on with it!
Grade: C
-Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion