
By: John Layman (writer/letters) and Rob Guillory (art/colors)
The Story: Tony eats a toe.
Review (with SPOILERS): This is one of those issues where I feel like I’m reviewing a 15 minute snippet of a TV show: I’m a little underwhelmed by the issue itself, but am also very confident that if I just sit here quietly….everything will rectify itself. So, take this review with a massive grain of salt. It’s akin to someone writing a detailed review of the second 20 minutes of Gravity.
This is an issue that is doing work. As Chew moves away from just being wet-your-pants-funny, it needs to develop more of a central story. And…..as that story develops, you’re going to get some transitional issues. This is one of those issues. It’s still got all the silly sight gags and funny food-powers, but it is a transitional issue where Layman and Guillory start to squarely position the players on the game-board.
After seeing the insane scene of Tony Chu and his daughter sitting down at the table to eat their family members’ toes, I was a little disappointed with how the Toni Chu apparition played out. I’m pretty sure we haven’t seen the last of Toni, but if this was “it,” it was kinda weak. It was almost too weak, because it leaves me assuming that Toni will appear again. I mean, this obviously cannot be the last of Toni…. Layman and Guillory have spent WAY too much time on Toni’s character and worked out the toe-thing in too much detail to let it come to nothing but THIS. So, when Toni makes he heroic return to assist Tony in 5-6 issues (like Obi-Wan on Hoth), I’ll kinda be expecting it, and that will weaken that future moment. Anyway, even though it was nice and touching and all that that Toni insisted Tony go help his brother Chow, it still felt a little too small; Toni isn’t dumb or rash, she would know how much time her apparition has left and wouldn’t waste it on a Chow Chu problem IF it meant that she wouldn’t have time to help Tony with the vampire cibopath problem.
I also liked seeing Mason Savoy start to come back into the picture. He’s such a clever character and it’s never been entirely clear what his deal is. I’m very curious to find out.
The art and sight gags are still spot-on in this issue. There’s just so much perfect about the faces that Guillory draws…..like the scene where Toni leans over to Tony and explains that the eroscribopictaros is “a food pornographer”. Her whole face is just like when a friend leans over to whisper a clarification…..except they speak way too loudly and everyone can hear them. The best sight gag this month was probably the sign behind Savoy in prison that says, “Supermax dating service: 555-SOAP Ouch!” Again, these sight gags really know where the line between decency and inappropriateness lies. I mean, that is a joke about prison rape. You have to handle that sort of thing very carefully, but they alway know how to make it funny without making it offensive. Bravo!
Conclusion: Not the hottest issue of Chew, but as this series develops more of an ongoing story, transitional issues will happen sometimes.
Grade: B
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion