By: Mark Waid (story), Loston Wallace (pencils), Bob Wiacek (inks), Hi-Fi (colors)

The Story: The Spirit on a plane.

The Review: Four months—that’s the amount of time it took to get from the first issue of this (four-issue!) mini to the second.  And that’s only after a month or so seeing the issue solicited for release week after week until my local comic book shop gave up and redacted the title from their weekly newsletter entirely.  I don’t know if this is the consequence of a dual-publisher team-up or what, but it better not be a running pattern.

The problem with shipping delays is, even though they have nothing to do with the story itself, they still affect the story’s impact.  Ordinarily, each issue only has to have enough substance to carry a reader through the next month.  When you have an issue that must now carry four months’ worth of entertainment on its back (and possibly four more—God forbid), you’re only setting it up for failure.  It gets even worse when, as here, the issue isn’t outstanding anyway.

It’s hard to feel anything more than nonplussed at how this story has transformed from what should have been a pulp mash-up into a screwball comedy with rom-com overtones.  Not that the whole love square between Denny, Cliff, Ellen, and Betty isn’t fun at certain moments, but the central complaint you have with this issue is how it shifts its weight to what should be entertaining asides instead of the mystery adventure that brought our heroes together.  Very early on in the issue—I daresay, as early as last issue—the campy flirtations among the characters get old and predictable, which means you spend a good chunk of the issue rolling your eyes.

Besides, I’m not sure how much I particularly enjoy seeing the ladies get reduced to mere love interests, whose only participation in the plot itself is incidental.  That’s par for the course where classic pulp is concerned, but this is a modern take on pulp, and slightly higher standards apply; some traditions can be let go, for the sake of a genre’s evolution.  Waid should know that better than anyone, having spent his run on Daredevil revitalizing the bombastic style of classic superhero comics while retaining contemporary sophistication.  So what’s with Betty fainting on the nearest man in every scene she appears in, or the ostensibly cultured Ellen cooing over Cliff’s machismo (“Oh!  Isn’t he brave?  And dashing?  In leather?”).*

You’d much rather that Waid, instead of paying tribute to the chauvinistic conventions of a bygone decade, spent more time developing the truly interesting ideas in the story.  The idea of the Octopus and Benedict Trask collaborating to control the television airwaves, from which they set up their personal network devoted to their illegal activities (“Station C-R-I-M-E is on the air!”), is rife with possibility, and there’s still the intriguing mystery of what exactly they did to the poor alderman who tried to defy them.  Old-school plane battles are well and good, but they don’t make a story lasting.**

You know what’s most baffling about the four-month break between issues?  The fact that during that time, the series couldn’t retain the terrific Paul Smith as artist and instead turned to Wallace, whose work is a clear step downwards.  I sincerely hope that it did not take him the entire four months to draw this issue; it doesn’t look like it, anyway.  His chosen style of figure-work is arguably on the level of Will Eisner at his most buffoon, but his storytelling is clumsy and clunky, more appropriate for slapstick than action or drama of any kind.  Dolan’s tears at his friend’s death are completely unconvincing, and the choreography and impact of the aforementioned plane battle is the equivalent of a 40s B-movie: awkward, obvious, and silly.

Conclusion: Waid still has a chance, if an increasingly smaller one, of redeeming the series, especially if he can get a stronger artist on his side.  However, the story is quickly becoming a reminder of why the pulp genre went out of style.

Grade: C

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Although Cliff is charming, in a sweetly dim, unintentional sort of way: “You’re really not from around here?  I just assumed you must be, originally.  Everyone knows all the prettiest blondes come from Califor-nye-ya.”

** Anyway, you’re 99 percent sure that Waid only included a plane attack just so that Cliff would have an excuse to do his Rocketeering.

– Did anyone else hear the Benny Hill theme song when Dolan started leering at Betty?

Grade

Conclusion