By: Charles Soule (story), Javier Pina & Kano (art) Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: Whoever knew the Green had an avatar apprenticeship program?

The Review: In light of a rather interesting article by Albert Ching of Comic Book Resources on the comeback of the annual, I must say that in comparison to most of the annuals I’ve read this year, this one is an excellent sample of the format and what it can do for an ongoing series’ storytelling.  Like Matt Fraction’s Hawkeye annual earlier this year, Soule’s crack at a Swamp Thing annual not only stands very well on its own, but advances the title’s cause as a whole.

Soule also does something with the annual that works very well and which I’m surprised other writers haven’t taken advantage of very often before.  He uses it as a fairly effective primer on the continuity behind both Swamp Thing and the Green, but more than that, he adds generously to the title’s mythos, allowing old and new readers to end the issue on fairly even footing.  Ever since this series was revived under the DC banner, we’ve been operating on a well-established understanding of how its world worked; Soule expands that understanding dramatically.

Perhaps his most important contribution is the personalization of the Parliament of Trees, particularly its individual members.  This is a big shift in the way we view the Parliament and its relationship to the Green.  Previously, it was easy to assume that both were practically one and the same, but now Soule advances the notion that the Parliament works pretty much as the bureaucracy its name suggests, rife with conflict, political and ideological, petty and substantial.*

In short order, Soule introduces us to two prominent members of the Parliament, a rather foppish noble who calls himself the Wolf and the Lady Weeds, a caustic, Miss Havisham type, down to the musty dress and veil.  Each serves a distinct purpose for both the story and to Alec, but Soule imbues each with some personality as well.  Although the Wolf’s hearty manner and repeated epithets of “my boy” make you take an instant distrust as to his intentions, you can’t help liking the guy and he does seem to genuinely support Alec as avatar (which gives us a sense of his values, as he says Seeder “shows a certain ruthlessness that some of us find quite attractive.”).

Obviously, if Alec has his backers, so does Seeder, and there’s a lot of intrigue to seeing the various members of the Parliament preening their favored sons.  And then there’s the Lady Weeds, who embodies the Green at its most ruthless.  Her horrifically efficient combat abilities match her summation of the Green’s ideals:

“The Green does not care who is its champion, as long as that person is the strongest.  Deep Down, the Green does not think, it does not feel—it only knows.”

Her only goal is to draw Alec (and his rival) out of their singular, superhero mindset about the avatar’s powers.  Her lessons are, quite honestly, a little redundant not only in their instruction that the avatar becomes the living embodiment of the earth itself, but also in the way they pit Alec’s humanity with the need for monstrosity.  It’s really the final scene, with “one of our greatest champions…the one we all compare ourselves to,” that proves truly instructive.  Spoiler alert—the meeting with the original Swamp Thing, the plant creature who believed himself to be Alec, has a lot of emotional power.  It gives Alec some catharsis from all the confusion and resentment that’s been building up since Soule took over the title, and it lets his predecessor remind us why he was such a compelling figure for so long to begin with.

Pina’s art is a near-perfect copy of Jesus Saiz, from the beautifully shaped figures to his straightforward, but effective command of the page for storytelling.  I can only describe his art by saying that it has a lot of charisma.  Even though you never see much than a sliver of Lady Weeds’ face behind her veil, her mocking glance comes through clearly.  This merely adds insult to the injury she wreaks upon Alec, which Pina depicts with thrilling brutality.  Kano and his more brutish work can’t help suffering in comparison, though fortunately, he gets only a small share of the issue.  Wilson has a limited palette of earth tones to work with, but he makes the most of it, rendering the Green in truly lush, verdant hues of bracken browns, mossy blacks, and of course, every shade of green you can think of.

Conclusion: This is what an annual should be used for: to build story-worlds in a way that the pressing demands of a typical monthly issue won’t allow.  It’s even better if you have strong creative power behind it, as you do here.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Kudos to Soule for actually detailing these tensions early on; it means he can avoid a sudden, poorly sold moment of drama within the Parliament later on, unlike the traitor Totem in Jeff Lemire’s Animal Man.

Grade

Conclusion