Here’s certainly a first on this website– a review for a piece fan fiction. For your pleasure, here’s the story for this rather unusual comic along with a review of the whole thing. Enjoy!

by Gerardo Preciado (Writer), Daniel Bayliss (Artist)


The Story
: The relationship between Batman and the Joker takes a sudden turns as things gets rather existential in their very last battle.

The Review
: I have to admit that when I usually hear about fan fiction, I never seem to be eager to follow up on the subject. It isn’t of course because every fans seems to have a low grasp on the subjects or seems to not care about the materials, but rather because of the stereotype attributed to them, mainly the one attached to the more ”slashy” pieces of fan fiction written. It’s not a fair point-of-view, of course, as there are fan films and other such works that are splendid, like the Dirty Laundry fan film about the Punisher. It’s not a case of quality rather than reputation per se.

It’s certainly a great thing then that works like this fan comic comes along to show me and many other skeptics the error of their way, as Gerardo Preciado shows us a very different version of one of the most famous antagonistic relations in comic book history: Batman and the Joker. While this work of fan fiction seems to actually delve on some of my fears when looking at fan fiction, it also seems to transcend this by playing smartly with many elements, twisting expectations while delivering a rather bizarre yet effective tale in the process.

The tale is overly simplistic in its premise, yet it is in its delivery that it seems to work so well, giving an overly dark overture to finish with a seemingly cruel, yet also sweet ending. Putting plenty of recognizable elements in his story, Perciado not only seems to give a retrospective on many of the more acclaimed stories like Alan Moore’s “The Killing Joke” and Frank Miller’s “Batman: Year One,” he even seems to reference a bit of the grotesque fun of the Adam West television serial. Mixing all of these moments together to produce an alternative take and a whole new perspective, this story truly sells its concept as it plays more on the self-tortured Bruce Wayne– the man that cannot seemingly get over the death of his parents.


This version of the Joker also seems to acknowledge many of the previous versions while providing a refreshing take, one with a whole new motivation… This is still the twisted clown prince of crime, yet the seemingly calm one that talks to Batman. He’s more at ease, despite everything that is going on around him and how violently he is treated. This take on the character makes him somewhat even more fearful than usual, as this portrayal makes a really great contrast to the more common psychologically disabled killer in most tales.

Something else that works, yet clearly could have turned out wrong is introducing a more mystic aspect to the story. Pushing reincarnation, the Buddhist version to be exact, to a character such as Batman could have easily misfired, yet the low amount of dialogue attributed to this aspect makes it work a lot better in the context of the story. It’s a bit uncertain whether the Joker is sincere or even if Batman truly believes what he is advancing, yet this ambiguity makes for an open-ended explanation about the whole thing; which is always a very nice thing for a story be bring to the table.

As for the art, Daniel Bayliss’ work is simply beautiful and unique. He goes for hyper expressivity with his characters. How he draws lips, how he portray the violence, the movements along with the expressions… All seem to put forward more hyperbolized emotions and reactions for Batman and Joker. This works great, considering the latter parts with the more emotional moments, where the past and the present merge together in a memorable moment. The ambiguity in the motivations and veracity of what is happening is also greatly represented on the pages, with the panels filled with enough space that it never retracts from the characters’ interactions and the reader’s search of additional meanings. Something else that is particularly memorable is the panel layout and the visual pacing, with the story moving forward at a great pace, never hurting the script and dialogue. The panel where Batman and the Joker are falling down is especially beautiful, hitting all the right notes in terms of emotional resonance. It may be a bit odd, but it’s powerful work from Bayliss.

His color work is a bit simpler, though. It is certainly efficient, as he is able to bring out basic contrasts while allowing for smaller details to receive just enough attention to count, yet not so that it distracts from the main elements. There is still a good variety, mind you, as the colorization never detracts from the art in itself. It settles in the middle of the sillier and darker aspects of the Batman mythology without removing anything in terms of visual effectiveness.

The Conclusion
: Bold, effective and twisted, this work of fan fiction is something quite unique that provides us a newer interpretation of these two beloved characters. Both Gerardo Preciado and Daniel Bayliss sure do deserve your attention, especially with the lovely art and ambiguous themes in this presentation.

Grade: A-

-Hugo Robberts Larivière

Grade

Conclusion