
By: Scott Snyder (story), Jim Lee (pencils), Scott Williams (inks), Alex Sinclair (colors)
The Story: Superman becomes the Luke Skywalker to Wraith’s Obi-Wan Kenobi.
The Review: I’ll be the first to admit that even though I’m very much a superhero fan, the genre has grown formulaic over the years, and not to an unnoticeable degree either. Still, I would discourage any broad generalizations about the integrity of the genre. If anything, it’s harder than ever to write a superhero comic that’s well-crafted, much less novel. Getting that balance of action-adventure while still telling a story with some teeth to it remains an elusive task.
That’s why Superman Unchained reveals the range of Snyder’s abilities even as some might say that the title wastes talents that might otherwise be spent on more legitimate, creator-owned pursuits. Few others in the business can engage in the blockbuster type of action you see here while retaining some credibility. Snyder’s scientific approach to the application of Superman’s powers is so convincing that you spend less time picking out the technical flaws of what’s going on, and more time relishing the action before you.
Wraith has been instrumental in this regard, instructing Superman on some very creative uses of their shared abilities. Watching Superman release a rapidfire barrage of heat-vision bursts (in the manner of laser blasts that usually get exchanged willy-nilly in sci-fi movies), or Wraith displaying his fine muscle control with a concentrated sonic blast from his throat, you’re reminded that there’s a lot more to the Man of Steel than just punching through obstacles.
At the same time that Wraith broadens Superman’s horizons about what he’s capable of, the older alien adds a word of caution: “As the years go by, you’ll learn how to do many things. Wondrous, terrible…” It’s that last word, “terrible,” that hints at the Wraith’s moral complexity. He may have an ends-means oriented rationale for warfare, but he is in no way unfeeling toward the destructive consequences. However, he implies that while he has the security of his nation to justify his actions, Superman’s is driven by purely personal values. Therein lies the inevitable conflict:
“You see what kind of enemies you make standing alone, above the governments of the world. Above the politics. One day you’ll cross a line, and they’ll send me after you. And I’ll do my duty.”
Superman protests such a forgone conclusion, accusing Wraith of simply being “cynical.” But isn’t it the responsibility of the nation’s military to expect the worst-case scenario? And doesn’t Superman’s rejection of such a scenario suggest some naivety on his part? He’s so sure of his own distinctions between right and wrong that he doesn’t take into account that they may conflict with those of others.
So Wraith may be correct after all, that Superman’s ethical overconfidence will eventually lead to his downfall, but it seems like everyone’s out to get our hero these days. If it’s not Wraith he has to worry about, it’s increasingly sophisticated Superman-killing technology (i.e. bullets that “emit low-frequency red solar radiation before impact, to soften the skin,” and ultraviolet collider missiles), or Luthor’s elaborate scheme to destroy his enemy by proxy, or an ex-Ascension member assuring Lois that “[Superman] won’t be alive much longer.” A frequent complaint of Superman comics is that he rarely seems sufficiently challenged, but Snyder reverses that trend by eroding at our hero’s dominance and by surrounding him with threats invisible even to his super-vision.
While Lee is no longer the superstar that he used to be (with a whole generation of superhero artists emulating and improving upon his model, how can he be?), there’s still a star quality to his work that suits a big, bombastic book like this one perfectly. Even when Superman’s recovering from attacks that make even the Man of Steel bleed, he exudes a grit and confidence that more than anything else proclaims his youth. The surrounding art also rises to the occasion, as splashy and striking as the hero himself.
I really don’t understand the point of bifurcating these issues into a chunky main feature and a two-page back-up that’s basically a part of the overarching storyline anyway. It’s not as if Dustin Nguyen’s art (with John Kalisz’s colors) do anything for the back-up’s plot that Lee couldn’t have.
Conclusion: If you read this Superman book, you don’t really need any of the others. Snyder gives us a series that is unabashedly in love with superhero conventions while also aspiring for more.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – A lot of writers have tried to give Superman a sense of humor that’s both gentle and not corny, and I think Snyder’s getting pretty close. After successfully using the wall of an armored security truck to tank through some giant robots, Superman remarks, “And I’ll be keeping my money with Secure-1 from now on.”
Grade
Conclusion