
By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie (art), Stephen Thompson & Mike Norton (inks) Matthew Wilson (colors)
The Story: All it takes is one kiss to save the universe.
The Review: Looking at the cover to this issue, there’s a bit of false advertising going on. It seems to suggest this title is about a group of diverse, confident, noble youths, working as a team to do some good in the world, when it’s actually about a god accomplishing his own ends and figuring himself out while a group of diverse, confident, noble youths try to do some good in the background. Heck, Loki isn’t even on the cover, yet he’s dominated the series thus far.
You can’t really blame Gillen for playing favorites; Loki has been a pet character for him since Journey Into Mystery and under Gillen’s pen, Loki has been more charismatic and interesting than he has in ages—outside the movies, of course. But when you hold a series out as a team effort, there are limits to how much you can train the spotlight on only one member. Once Gillen reveals Leah as a magical byproduct of his own guilty conscience,* making Loki his own antagonist, it takes the series’ singular focus to a kind of excess.
Again, you can’t deny the emotional power Gillen brings to Loki’s confession, nor the psychological messiness it invites. Indeed, Loki had more than one reason to keep his secrets, as revealing them forces him to confront the very nature of his being. Reduced to a writhing fetal position in Mother’s dimension, he stammers, “I’m not the murderer Loki. I’m the murder weapon Loki. I’m a copy the old Loki made to lie in wait for his innocent self. I’m not the murderer. I’m just identical to him. I had no choice.”
This doesn’t feel like one of Loki’s attempts to “talk his way out of this,” as America recognizes, but that doesn’t make his claims any less self-serving or unbelievable. This being comics, it’s entirely possible that he really is just a copy left by his old self as a survival tactic. But the fact that he admits he’s “identical” to the “murderer Loki” renders that theory moot, and besides, his very confession proves that he had anything but “no choice” to do what he did.
Okay, enough of Loki; what about all those other kids you saw on the cover? Billy and Teddy are the only ones who come even close to being considered secondary characters on this series, and Gillen draws their storyline to a neat, deservedly happy close. That said, even he can’t help falling back on some old clichés to do it, and no amount of self-aware sarcasm (Loki: “Oh, ugh. Is love really going to save us all?”) can cover up that fact.
However, superhero comics are by nature idealistic, and no one is going to diminish the power of love. Yes, Prodigy sort of minimizes the true gravity of Teddy’s existential concerns by calling it “nonsense. Who cares? It doesn’t matter,” and encouraging him to just embrace his feelings. But the alternative is to have a romance like Noh-Varr and Kate’s, born of impulse, living on an affectionate exchange of amusing remarks, then dying in the most awkward fashion possible. So to Loki’s disgust about love saving us all, we should shoot back as America does: “Of course it is. Anyone who thinks otherwise gets stomped into paste.”
As this issue begins to draw Gillen’s Young Avengers run to a close, he has the dual obligation of giving a strong wrap-up of what the series has been all about as well as leaving some a few loose ends to come back to later, should anyone choose to do so. He succeeds on both counts, but barely. Gillen wants to persuade you that these kids aren’t just the poor man’s version of the Avengers, but the real deal. Unfortunately, he sort of defeated that aim by spending so little time developing them as individuals or as a team, and revealing that this whole world-threatening crisis they just averted was due to the actions of one of their own. No wonder he’s forced to make the point explicitly a couple times in this issue: “We’re the Avengers.” And frankly, even with not-Patriot still out there, mumbling ambiguous one-liners (except one: “No one escapes. Thankfully.”), there doesn’t seem to be all that much left for our heroes to return to, if they ever get their own ongoing again.
For the big finale to this storyline, McKelvie keeps up his A-game, with beautiful renderings of every character that falls into his hands. On the other hand, there’s a lot of action in the issue, which only exposes his struggles to generate a sense of movement from the characters. Even the liveliest scenes more often than not look like everyone decided to strike a pose and freeze in place. In terms of layout and storytelling, though, McKelvie consistently knocks it out of the park; Billy’s temporary ascendance as the demiurge is spectacular and awesome, even more so once Wilson pours a whole universe of colors into it.
Conclusion: Highly ambitious, but ultimately small in scope. Despite the universal threats involved, the story easily reduces to the conflicts of a few select characters, undermining any sense of teamwork from the title.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * At least, I’m pretty sure that’s what she is. It explains the Loki-green outlines of her dialogue, at least.
Grade
Conclusion