
By: Charles Soule (story), Jesus Saiz (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)
The Story: What Buddy didn’t want for Christmas: a throwdown with Swamp Thing.
The Review: You don’t need to be an English major to recognize certain archetypical characters and relationships in storytelling. For any consumer of popular fiction, one dynamic that should be particularly familiar is that of teacher-student, also known as master-apprentice or mentor-mentee. Sooner or later, to the point of being a foregone conclusion, there’ll always be that tension when the pupil wants to know more than the instructor is willing to give.
Jason Woodrue fits very neatly into the subservient half of this age-old relationship. His development from well-meaning, tree-hugging nerd into a manic-obsessive pawn of both the supernatural and occult follows well-worn paths of countless overeager students before him, and while Soule executes these old tropes with great credibility, he does little to set Jason apart from other desperately ambitious characters in the same class.
The problem is that Soule, or Alec, or perhaps both, mischaracterize the moment when Jason’s intentions changed. “[H]e wanted,” they claim. “He became obsessed with what he wasn’t, instead of what he was.” But this seems to contradict the scene we witnessed with our very eyes in #24, when a dismissive, somewhat condescending Alec ignored Jason’s feelings and subsequently drove the ex-scholar to challenge—and ultimately defeat—Alec at his own game. Perhaps Jason did secretly always plan to usurp the avatar’s position, but it was Alec’s own missteps which made Jason take action.
Aside from that, there’s a certain consistency to Jason’s motivations, which are mainly fueled by desperation, a willingness to take unsavory means to advance himself—the ultimate trademark of his archetype. His goal isn’t primarily to hurt people, otherwise he’d never have spent so much time as Seeder giving aid to them. But the grunt-work he does for several prominent occultists (most of them decidedly evil),* in exchange for lessons in stretching his Green-given powers, proves that Jason doesn’t take much stock in human life when his own interests are at stake.
That’s really the fascinating part about Jason; he’s clearly and morally contemptible (“I’d kill you now, Capucine, but I’m very busy!”), but only by human standards. Obviously, the Green doesn’t care, but this situation can’t stand for long. In the meantime, Jason has the opportunity to create a lot of mischief with his power, though inexperience hampers him for now, as demonstrated by his humiliating defeat to Buddy Baker, a mere agent (and exiled, at that) of the Red. That’s not to say that Buddy doesn’t earn the win, though, in a great moment of triumph that he’s never gotten in his own title. Shrugging off Jason’s grisly attack, Buddy scoffs at Jason’s gleeful murder of every living creature in a three-mile radius:
“Plants don’t see all the animals, any more than animals see all the plants. There’s an ant on a boulder a mile away. You missed that. Ants are strong. There’s a worm ten feet below us. Worms can heal. And a hawk is looking at us right now, a few thousand feet up. Missed that too. Hawks can fly.”**
I am so happy to see Saiz on an ongoing basis again. He’s always been one of the most reliable hitters for DC, and this issue shows why. Everything looks just right—not necessarily outstanding, if you’re talking about sheer creativity, but perfectly formed, with all the texture and detailing that so many other others rarely even bother with. Like Jamie McKelvie, Saiz has a little difficulty getting his pristine figures into the semblance of real movement, but otherwise, there’s very little to complain about, especially if you have Wilson to apply his amazingly lush colors over the visuals.
Conclusion: Slight gaps in the corners of the art and script prevent the issue from rising to a truly memorable level, but facially, this is a more than solid product on most levels.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Alec should take note that Constantine contributed to Jason’s tutelage at some point.
** This seems to confuse the nature of Buddy’s powers a little. I didn’t realize that proximity affected Buddy’s powers that much.
Grade
Conclusion