By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Danny Miki (inks) and FCO Plascencia (colors)

The Story: Bruce, Batman and Gordon continue to work on their relationship while Dr. Death prowls the city.

Review (with SPOILERS): What I’ve always found remarkable about Scott Snyder’s work since he burst on the scene 4-5 years ago is how he seems immune to the dreaded “transitional issue”.  You know what I mean…   In typical modern comicbooking, the 5-6 issue story arc is popular because it collects easily for publication as a trade paperback.  It is common for the middle issues of those arcs to be really boring because the writers could never figure out how to link the cool concept that was introduced in issue #1 with the climax and resolution in issues #4 and #5.

By all rights, this Batman #26 should be a transitional issue:  It is in the middle of the Zero Year Bat-Epic and it is even in the middle of the story-within-the-epic that began with issue #24.  So, how does Snyder avoid having a dreaded transitional issue?

  • Capullo: Art is the ultimate buffer for a comic series.  In chemistry you use a buffer to maintain a certain pH in a solution because the buffer makes it so you have to add/subtract a LOT of other chemicals to move away from the buffered pH.  Greg Capullo’s art fills that same role for Batman.  His art is so routinely awesome that you can’t really have a poor issue with him holding the pencils.  I could hand Capullo a draft of this review and he could do a compelling sequential drawing of me at my kitchen table at 0500, drinking my tea, charging my devices while typing away as I reference the issue on my iPad…   Capullo is just a monster of modern comic art.  He makes even the routine panels sing more than they have any right to.  I LOVE how Capullo draws Gordon.  You can just tell he enjoys drawing the guy.  Capullo’s Gordon has a bit of a swagger about him; he’s been beaten down to the point where he’s lost his youthful and naive idealism and just doesn’t give a shit anymore as long as he can do what works.  His Gordon looks like a man who is liberated by the fact that his bosses hate him: He’s resigned himself to not getting promoted and now he’ll just do the job that he is so good at.
  • Multiple stories: I’ve noticed a pattern with Snyder’s writing in these Bat-Epics and also in his American Vampire work: He never has just one story going on.  So, even though this issue is somewhat transitional, the stories are all breaking in subtly different ways and at slightly different times.  Have you ever been to one of those water parks that has a wave-making machine in the BIG pool?  You know….everyone paddles out there and there is one cool wave every 5 minutes?  That is the model of typical superhero writing.  Snyder is more like the real ocean: wave after wave after wave.  Some of the waves are better for surfing than others, but there is always something splashing around you while you wait for that one perfect wave to ride.  Furthermore, Snyder always gives you something to look forward to, much like those moments when you look out to the horizon and see a wave coming that could be “the good one”.  Just in this issue, Snyder has this Dr. Death story, the growing Bruce-Gordon relationship and the Batman-Police relationship.  If Snyder was focused on just ONE of these stories, this issue would have sagged and been boring, but by keeping in busy he’s giving us a lot to react to and that overpowers the traditional weakness of the transitional issue.
  • Characters over Concept: The most powerful thing about this whole Zero Year story is that it isn’t a story based on “concept”.  The power derives from the characters in the story.  Think about it… There’s nothing conceptually brilliant about telling an origin story for Batman and his early adventures with Alfred and Gordon.  It’s kinda standard fare.  Snyder CAN do big concept stuff (see: Court of Owls) where the story has a real hook to it.  This Zero Year lacks a hook and that is both a blessing and a weakness.  The weakness is that the first few issues may not be as mind-bendingly awesome as the first few issues of a concept-based story.  But the blessing is that you suffer less from transitional issues because there is never a lull when the novelty of “the hook” wears off.  We already know that Snyder can write excellent characters…and he’s doing it again in Zero Year with Bruce, Gordon and Alfred!  So, in this issue where the action should sag a little bit, he just powers through because we know who Bruce is, we know who Alfred is and we’re learning a LOT about Gordon.  We like them and just enjoy watching these characters interact with each other.

Add it all up and you have a great Bat-story.  It probably isn’t the strongest issue of Zero Year, but it also doesn’t make people wish they could fast-forward to the end.

We end the issue with that classic scene of Batman tossing up his cape to shield-himself from a hail of bullets – we’ve seen that a zillion times – only for the bullets to shred the cape.  I wonder about this scene…..  I’ve always thought that the bullet-proof cape was absurd because it would be like one of those lead-lined aprons they put on you when the doctor takes x-rays.  I mean, how do you fight crime in THAT???  I wonder if Snyder also thinks the cape is dumb?  Or will this just be a young-Batman mistake and the Bulletproof Bat-Cape will make an appearance before the story is over?  Regardless, I’ll bet that Gordon will be pretty suspicious about why Bruce Wayne has a bullet wound in his leg…..  And isn’t that where the story is headed?  To that moment when Gordon KNOWS about Bruce/Batman, but doesn’t really care so long as both Bruce and Batman are his allies against crime in Gotham?

Conclusion: A textbook example of how to avoid the transitional issue.  Snyder and Capullo… Powering through quicksand that would swallow lesser creators…

Grade: A-

-Dean Stell

PS: Don’t miss the back-up story one bit….

 

Grade

Conclusion