
By: Geoff Johns (story), Doug Mahnke (art), Christian Alamy, Mark Irwin, Keith Champagne (inks), Gabe Eltaeb, Tony Avina, Rod Reis (colors)
The Story: Owlman exchanges one family for one of his choice.
The Review: I’m not the biggest fan of Big Events from the Big Two, but I have to admit that there’s no better way to capture the collision of worlds than to have the effects spread to a large swath of titles. A story with that kind of scope requires more than just one title to squeeze in all its material. Forever Evil, for example, would have been a far shallower affair if it didn’t have Justice League to flesh out its more interesting parts.
The Crime Syndicate would have suffered especially in their credibility as antagonists. When paired against the less extreme villains of Earth-Prime in Forever Evil, the Syndicate seems caricaturized, even campy. Their appearances in Justice League moderate these problems somewhat by placing the Syndicate in the overall seedier context of Earth-3, but still leave room for confusion. Contrary to how it presents itself, Earth-3 doesn’t simply reverse the morality of characters on Earth-Prime. There are slight hiccups in Earth-3’s ethical scheme producing what you can only call an interesting inconsistency to its denizens.
Owlman’s origin story probably has more than the usual share of complications. That Martha and Thomas Wayne-3 are respectively domineering and sadistic is no more surprising than the violence of Ultraman’s parents (both sets of them). It’s the Wayne children who defy expectation, with Thomas Junior as psychotic as his Earth-Prime counterpart and Bruce displaying compassion that the rest of his family lacks (“I’ve changed my mind. I don’t want to hurt Mom and Dad.”). These qualities fly in the face of Earth-3’s entire shtick, but to what purpose? Are these simply oversights on Johns’ part or deliberate subversions?
Usually, I’d lean towards the former theory, but this time I think there’s a growing body of evidence that Johns is going for a more nuanced vision of Earth-3 than we’ve previously seen. Just as Ultraman’s indoctrination as an infant may have led to his unfeeling arrogance as an adult, perhaps it’s the Wayne parents’ flawed upbringing (and Alfred-3’s manipulation) which enabled Thomas to become the parricidal lad we see in the issue’s opening and Bruce his temporary accomplice. It’s possible that the Syndicate’s evil is not so much inherent as conditioned, which gives them far more possibilities as characters.
Already, these subtle changes are playing out in unexpected ways—spoiler alert—like the alliance between Owlman and Nightwing. Owlman’s attachment to Dick Grayson, no matter which Earth he comes from, is a strange blend of affection and fetish. His regret and guilt over Dick-3’s death is real, but that hardly absolves him of what he did to gain that relationship in the first place: “I had arranged their deaths. I had murdered them. And I did so for one reason. So that he would bond emotionally to me.” It’s that desire for an emotional bond from Dick in particular that feels predatory, as if Johns is drawing on homophobic accusations against the Golden Age Batman and Robin’s intimacy.*
It’s not often that an artist can convey so much of a character’s personality by appearance alone without resorting to comical exaggerations, but Mahnke can, apparently. One look at Martha and Thomas-3 and you know these aren’t the Wayne parents you’re used to: Thomas’ face is sallow, drawn, with fretful pinches and furrows on his brow, and his head is tipped forward, suggesting a man who always keeps his eyes to the ground; in contrast, Martha always has her nose in the air, her hair tightly lacquered back, a sharp angle to her perfectly groomed eyebrows. The number of inkers remain a slight stumbling block for Mahnke, as it results in his work looking smooth and tight early in the issue, then rougher, scragglier later on.
Conclusion: There are signs that a more complex plot may be at work, if only in the Syndicate’s unexpected characterizations, but otherwise, Forever Evil remains as straightforward an Event as others like it.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Which I think would be a pretty clever, if twisted, choice. This is Earth-3!
– Hm. So Mr. Bertinelli is the lucky gangster Owlman has chosen to run his new empire in Gotham-Prime. Wonder if ol’ Bertinelli has a daughter.
Grade
Conclusion