
By: Charles Soule (story), Tony S. Daniel (pencils), Batt (inks), Tomev Morey (colors)
The Story: Wonder Woman wraps up Zod for Superman’s Christmas gift.
The Review: One of the big concerns I have about Batman/Superman is that despite boasting two primo stars as its leads, it would still turn out to be a rather inconsequential title, much like Superman/Batman before it. It’s not hard to see how this paradox arises. Writing two icons means twice the amount of continuity you can mangle. Restraint is key in these circumstances; it’s the only way to ensure you don’t ruffle anyone’s feathers, particularly other writers’.
It’s too early to see how far Soule is willing (or allowed) to stretch his legs on this series, but at the very least he gets to make a major character’s official introduction to the new DCU. While Zod’s first appearance is a relatively quiet affair, witnessed by only a few heroes, he immediately upsets everyone’s balance, from Superman, stunned to meet yet another surviving Kryptonian, to Steve Trevor, who wonders aloud, “[H]ow many of these people can Earth really handle?” This alone should signal to anyone new to the character that Zod’s existence does not bode well.
I suspect, however, that few people can claim to be truly “new” to Zod, especially after Man of Steel’s summer run. Almost all of us know he’s bad news. The only real mystery is what xenophobic plan he hopes to unleash on Earth this time. His meek and slightly sycophantic (“You have much of the great Jor-El in your face.”) interactions with Clark ring patently false, and indicate a long con. After all, if he’s studied Earth enough to learn its language, there’s no way he could be oblivious to its culture, especially where its heroes are concerned.
Zod’s keen interest on finding Faora also gives away Soule’s intention for using these specific villains for this specific title. The past couple issues have seen Diana pushing Clark to take on some of her warrior’s mentality, and Zod is a warrior’s warrior, someone who manufactured a war of worlds just so he could have something to fight. If Clark can put some of Diana’s training to use in his evitable confrontation with Zod, that’s at least one positive out of their relationship. A showdown between Faora and Diana will be fun, too.*
Soule-written issues usually divide their time equally between action and character development, and this one is no different. It’s worth observing, however, that while Clark and Diana are still in their honeymoon phase, so to speak, their dynamic mostly consists of the usual cutesy tensions that make up so much of fictional romances, e.g., Diana fretting over what to get Clark for Christmas. Sweet as these fringe plotlines are, we’d be far better served seeing more of the couple together, displaying whatever chemistry they can muster.
This is crucial because as long as their most intimate scenes in the issue are with other people—Hessia for Diana and Bruce for Clark—it’ll be very hard to place much stock in their coupling. Obviously, there’s a history between Clark and Bruce that Diana doesn’t share, but it’s still amusing (and a little pathetic) to see the two men show more genuine affection and familiarity with each other than Clark does with Diana. Bruce: “Remember that you grew up a dumb farmboy. In some ways, important ways, you’re just like everyone else.”
“Says the billionaire master warrior genius crimefighter.”
There’s no question that Daniel is one of DC’s great mainstream artists, just by the exterior perfection of his figures alone. Jim Lee’s influence is certainly there, in the sharp angles to his lines, but there’s greater control and tightness to his work (Batt’s influence, no doubt) that make the characters look particularly striking. He does struggle with their physicality, though. For some reason, they tend to keep their arms stiff and close to their bodies, which looks quite awkward in an action sequence. Morey’s a very direct sort of colorist—everything’s the color it should be—but his lighting really makes the visuals pop, which is about all you can ask for from a big, splashy title like this.
Conclusion: While Soule’s execution is relatively faultless, the material, especially with his two leads, doesn’t quite have that zing you’re looking for just yet.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Or one between Diana and Zod. Or a rematch between Zod and J’onn.
– “Please Diana. For old time’s sake.” Oof. You sure you want to be pulling that card for this, Steve?
Grade
Conclusion