By: Amanda Connor & Jimmy Palmiotti (story), Chad Hardin (art), Alex Sinclair (colorist)

The Story: She’s like Marlo Thomas in That Girl, only with a criminal record!

The Review: I didn’t have plans to review this series, and I didn’t even check out the gimmicky and somewhat controversial #0 issue.  I’ve always liked Harley Quinn fine, but she never really interested me until Ales Kot had his way with her on Suicide Squad.  There, she had a razor-sharp intellect that revealed itself at her most bubbly, chaotic moments, not unlike the man who inspired her.  I’ll be honest; I had little confidence Palmiotti could capture that same duality.

And he doesn’t.  Instead, like most writers, he and Connor keep Quinn’s cunning under wraps, focusing more heavily on her comedic side.  It’s not a bad choice.  Her sheer vivacity has a lot of charm, and she takes such delight when giving in to impulse that it’s hard not to enjoy it, despite yourself.  Who else in the DCU can convincingly break out into song in a moment of pure joy, belting the first bar of “The Sound of Music”* as she twirls in her newly inherited apartment

This is what sets Harley apart not only from the Joker (or the plainly redundant Joker’s Daughter), but from everyone else in the DCU.  No one will deny she’s a twisted criminal, but there’s also no one else who has that same lust for life, not even among the heroes—which is sort of a clever bit of commentary in itself.  At the same time, she’s much more purposeful in her violence than Joker, who unleashes his depravities for its own sake.  Harley requires a trigger, even if a small one, which makes her crimes easier to take, even sweet-natured in a way.

Besides, Harley does display a surprising willingness to play things straight when left to her own devices.  Thrust into the position of a landlady who must generate a hefty 6 grand a month to keep her new digs, Harley rises to the challenge by taking on a couple jobs, both legitimate, and both opening all sorts of interesting storytelling possibilities for her.  Joining an all-woman roller-derby team is perfect for her, of course, but it’s her decision to go back to counseling that’s really intriguing.  For one thing, it proves that hers is a very controlled craziness, since she can still manage to say things like, “I am very familiar with that type of patient,” without arousing suspicion.  For another, you can’t help wanting to see the kind of “therapy” she’ll be inflicting on these potentially criminal patients who’ll be coming into her care.

Connor-Palmiotti top things off by surrounding Harley with the perfect atmosphere and set of supporting characters.  Coney Island offers that blend of fun and seediness that suits Harley to a tee, and taking residence along with a passel of side/freak-show acts couldn’t be a better choice.  Now Big Tony is no Grills (the late, great tenant of Hawkeye fame), being less of a good ol’ boy and more of a saucy dwarf in a fishnet shirt, but he serves the same role of confidante and advisor, putting Harley on the right track with some sensible, New Yorkish advice:

“One local newspaper with help wanted ads, a highlight pen to circle the leads, a giant coffee—two sugars, no milk—and one authentic Brooklyn everything bagel, toasted, with cream cheese.”*

The last time I saw Hardin’s work, I was completely unimpressed, to say the least.  Somewhere along the way, though, he has upped his game by several levels because this is truly impressive work he’s putting into Harley Quinn.  I should note that Sinclair’s shimmering, vibrant colors can make almost anything seem like top-notch art, but Hardin gives him a good foundation to work with, balancing slapstick and sophistication as well as our heroine does herself.  It’s the expressions that really kill it: a roller-derby girl’s bulging eyes and tongue as she fights off Harley’s chokehold; a weeping dachshund and Harley’s reactionary transition from drippy-nosed to nuclear-eyed.  It’s a level of cartoon comedy we haven’t seen in a while and with Harley, Hardin makes it work.

Conclusion: An almost shockingly strong start to a fairly unconventional series from DC, proving that taking risks really can produce the most profitable results.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * In what I imagine to be the voice of Ethel Merman, because who else would it be?

** Genius.  With that kit, I can pretty much conquer the world, myself.

– “[I]s there anything more boring than a married couple that…”  Can’t help being a little tantalized as to where that line was going.  “…that’s into wine tasting”?  “…that brushes their teeth together”?  What, what?

Grade

Conclusion