
By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie, Emma Viceli, Christian Ward, Annie Wu (art), Matthew Wilson, Lee Loughridge, Jordie Bellaire (colors)
The Story: You can bet this evening will end with a rousing chorus of “We Are Young”.
The Review: So we’ve come to the conclusion of Young Avengers’ relatively short-lived run, and what a conflicted run it has been. While it was certainly the It Girl series when it premiered, much of its hip luster has rubbed off since, revealing more of a mixed bag underneath. As you can see from the activity on the Comic Book Resources forums, there’s a great deal of debate on whether Young Avengers has lived up to its ambitious promise.
I can cop out and simply cite some hard numbers, like the fact that last month’s issue sold only 23,790 copies to get a Comichron rank of 92.* Diehard fans may protest that numbers don’t mean everything, and they’re right, but these dispiriting figures do indicate a disconnect between the story Gillen’s been telling and the wider readership. Something along the way must have turned people off, to the tune of an almost 50,000 sales drop from the first issue.
I can only speak for myself, but I have a feeling I’m not alone when I say that I bought into a Young Avengers ongoing expecting to see the Young Avengers front-and-center on something like a monthly basis, not whenever Gillen can fit them in between the seams of his Loki plot. It didn’t help either that much of that plot’s intrigue was lost on anyone who never read Gillen’s Journey Into Mystery run. Despite that, nearly all of Young Avengers’ most important events seemed designed to expose and develop Loki only, which kept the rest of the team on the fringes in their own series.
It’s not much of an exaggeration to say this issue features the most sustained team interaction of the title’s entire run thus far. Seeing as how we’re on the penultimate issue, these efforts come obviously too late. With Loki removed, we finally get some variation in the gang’s dynamics, from the awkward attempts at friendliness between America and Kate to the semi-hostile discussion between Billy and David. Considering how natural and entertaining these exchanges are, it’s baffling why Gillen didn’t do more of this kind of thing from the start.
This issue also highlights how minimal the character work has been for most of the team. Only now does Gillen let us into America’s origin, which could and should have been the basis of an entire issue or arc in itself. Gillen is forced to skip over a whole period of her life to get from A to B, and it is clearly that period where America’s currently flinty personality was formed. At least it reveals her previously unexplained attachment to Billy, and we get a brand new world out of it: the Utopian Parallel, which “sits apart, out of time, the purest incarnation of the Demiurge’s breath. A land born of his final unbinding of magic…”
This issue also highlights another flaw to the series as a whole. Though superficially radical, Young Avengers relied on a fair amount of cliché as many other titles. Kate’s send-off to Noh-Varr, for example, has a modern tone but ultimately finishes on as corny a note as any good rom-com: “You know…the girl of your dreams? You had her. And you were so locked inside your head you didn’t even notice.”** And just to make the resolution to that whirlwind romance even neater, Gillen brings back Tommy to leave Kate on a hopeful note, even if he has to dumb down her usual good sense to make it work. Rather than question how Tommy managed to return seemingly unscathed and unaffected, Kate decides, “You know, I really don’t care,” and proceeds to cozy up to him, regardless.
There’s a mish-mash of artistic styles going on here, with little effort to meld any of it together, but while our guest artists all have a similarly sketchy thing going on, it’s McKelvie who stands out with his clean, polished lines. Even so, every artist shows off his or her stuff with great flair, and their respective colorists let loose with splashes of eye-catching hues, all jumbled up in as invigorating a fashion as the lighting scheme in the hippest club.
Conclusion: A solid issue in its own right, but one that also exposes many of the defects of the series as a whole.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * To put it into perspective, Batman ’66 #5 ranks nearly ten spots higher with nearly 3,000 more readers (so to speak). The fact that Marvel’s premiere team of young superheroes is being outpaced by an adaptation of a cult TV show from the 60s is not terrific. It’s also worth mentioning that My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic outstrips both of these series, and it’s about as old as Young Avengers, so…
** Only the extraterrestrial Noh-Varr could possibly be foreign enough to not roll his eyes at the line.
Grade
Conclusion