
By: Robert Kirkman (writer), Charlie Adlard (pencils), Stefano Gaudiano (inks), Cliff Rathburn (gray tones) and Russ Wooton (letters)
The Story: Tides turn in the war between Rick and Negan.
Review (with SPOILERS): After the weird, messy issue that we got last month, this was a return to normalcy for The Walking Dead. It wasn’t a great issue, but at least it wasn’t filled with weird art and odd story-telling constructs.
The main plot point of this issue was Negan turning the tide on Rick & Company. This happens via Ezekiel’s failed attack and I’m not sure how to feel about this. On one hand, it seems strangely unplanned for Rick’s army to have no contingency planning for a failed attack. The upshot of Ezekiel’s failure is that not only did he fail to wipe out the outpost of Negan he was responsible for, but that such outpost would then be free to help Negan out of his zombie problem from a few issues ago. As we saw by the end of the issue, this allowed Negan to “steal a march” on Rick.
It just seems really odd that there was no plan if any prong of the attack failed to avoid just this sort of problem. What happens is that Ezekiel basically went home and cried for a few hours, when instead he should’ve sent a runner to Rick to let him know what happened. Why didn’t they think of this in advance? Why didn’t Michonne suggest it to him? I mean, it seemed like Rick had everything else planned out, right? On the other hand, these guys are all amateur generals, so it isn’t too unsurprising that they would overlook something like this. Probably if Abraham was still alive, he would have pointed out this problem with Rick’s plan.
Let’s just say that “mistakes were made” and leave it at that….
One thing I did enjoy was the twist that Negan had sent a zombified Holly back into Rick’s arms. I was totally surprised. I assumed that Negan had done something terrible to her like cut out her tongue or that it wasn’t really Holly under the mask. I actually did a double-take before I figured out that she was a zombie. It isn’t as if one zombie will destroy all of Rick’s compound. Michonne would take Holly’s head off in about 2 seconds. But it does put Rick off balance right when Negan decides to attack. I also like that it’s another example of humans using the zombies as a weapon.
There were also a few nice bits from the supporting cast too. I enjoyed Michonne giving Ezekiel some tough love, and I wonder if that’s the end of their relationship. She certainly seemed to be disgusted with him. It was also nice to see Rosita and at least hear about Eugene’s ammunition production facility. I’ve always liked those two. It almost seemed like Rosita and Eugene might now be a couple. Let’s hope that’s the case. I kinda like the idea of Rosita having to accept that in the apocalypse, shacking up with the dumpy science teacher isn’t so bad. And I like how Eugene has gone from pariah after the whole walkie-talkie incident to a useful member of the group. He’s actually learning how to do new stuff and producing goods and services. I feel like these civilians in Alexandria should be doing a lot more reading about blacksmithing and gardening and whatnot…
The other big surprise for me is what didn’t happen. I fully expected Negan to somehow attack Alexandria while Rick was out kicking ass and taking names. It just seemed to be set up so nicely with Carl/Andrea/Michonne “safe” at home while Rick and Ezekiel were out doing the dangerous work. Oh well… I do wonder if Kirkman meant to drop hints that there could be such an attack as a bit of misdirection. Or was I just seeing things that weren’t really there?
The art is much improved in this issue. It isn’t back to the highest levels of art we’ve seen in The Walking Dead, but it isn’t bothersome either. It’s fine, adequate and tells the story just fine. That’s all I ask of the art in TWD. I am starting to think that the decision to go bi-weekly for this storyline was a poor one. Just imagine all the folks who read this in trade paperback, they’re going to wonder why the art looks funny.
Conclusion: An interesting twist and a change in the dramatic flow of the War. Definitely entertaining…
Grade: B
-Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion