![]()
By: Charles Soule (story), Jesus Saiz (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)
The Story: Alec feels he’s too young for retirement.
The Review: From the moment Soule removed Alec from his position as avatar, there was no question that Alec would inevitably get it back, just whether it would happen sooner or later. Had it been put up for a vote, I would have elected for later. Soule has proven so adept at fleshing out the world of the Green that having Alec roam around the place, uncovering its secrets and denizens while searching for a way back, sounds like a great idea to me.
Seems like I was outvoted. I suppose we shouldn’t be surprised at this rush to return Alec to the physical world, what with Woodrue’s rampage against anything that doesn’t have roots. The Wolf may tease Alec’s “terrible, innocent urgency” in wanting to stop the violence before it gets worse, but that only reveals Wolf’s own shortage of humanity. Given the circumstances, Alec must get back as soon as possible, even if it caps any potential world-building.
Unfortunately, once Alec makes the blasphemous choice to escape the Green, it’s not like he’ll ever be welcomed back to explore it further, even if leaving wasn’t a one-way street as Lady Weeds reveals. Even sadder is that his actions at the end of the issue pretty much seal away most of the interesting developments Soule has made since last year’s annual. What was the point of establishing all those great characters and concepts if the intent was to put an end to it all? Sure, the Parliament was a massive thorn in Alec’s side, but think of all the intrigue we lose by having Alec end them. I, for one, was looking forward to the Parliament’s next referendum, which they hadn’t held since 1918, according to Lady Weeds.
Speaking of whom, you’re most sorry to see figures like Weeds and Wolf go, so soon after Soule brought them into existence. Their voices added diversity and new rhythm to Swamp Thing that’ll be sorely missed, particularly the caustic Weeds. Sure, she was mad as pants, but by golly, she was entertaining. Whether it’s the disturbing sight of her gouging out the flesh of an elephant as she remarks, “I’ve always loved children,” or the way she inflicts her flowery sense of humor mostly to mock Alec (“A marigold would get more votes than you.”), she was exactly the kind of foil he needed to draw out his aggressive side.*
Besides the rushed pace of the plot, there are a few flaws in the way things play out. The Green, without the Parliament to counsel it, seems a bit too vulnerable to manipulation, with Alec conning them with a promise he (presumably) has no intention of keeping. This makes usurping the avatar position from Woodrue a bit too easy, on top of an already straightforward, if clever, escape from the Green.
What makes you especially sad about the loss of the Parliament is you won’t get to see more of Saiz’s awesome designs for the various members. Though rife with all the foliage you’d expect from past Swamp Things, their cultural origins are always delightfully clear: a Celtic warrior, a Russian Cossack, an African matriarch, what looks to be a Neanderthal/primate, and a freaking velociraptor, which, as we all know, just makes everything better. Aside from the sheer beauty of his art, Saiz has found the perfect balance, as all good mainstream artists should, of making his visuals look fully-fleshed and perfectly posed without losing too much of their dynamism. The battle Alec, Weeds, and the Parliament is all too brief, but the flow of the action runs smoothly from panel to panel, never once getting too static. And obviously, Wilson can do no wrong when it comes to colors.
Conclusion: For an issue full of game-changing moments, there’s a distinct shortage of impact, probably because it moves too fast to have as much as it should. The execution is sound; the timing is not.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Green Arrow, take note of Alec’s response to Lady Weeds’ innuendo and try to apply it Shado: “If I knew, I wouldn’t be asking! Tell me!!”
– Did Alec just restore a few members of the Parliament back to their human state, there? Or are they just corpses?
Grade
Conclusion