By: Charles Soule (story), Tony S. Daniel (pencils), Batt & Sandu Florea (inks), Tomev Morey (colors)

The Story: Like certain Phantom Zone super-criminals, the truth about comes out.

The Review: One thing you have to remember about Superman and Wonder Woman as a couple is that these two are highly competent and intelligent individuals.  They perceive the obstacles in their relationship, both from within and without, as well as you do, which is probably why Clark strove so hard to keep their hook-up a secret and why Diana repeatedly tries to convince him to do the opposite.  Outing them hasn’t mooted the conflict, only changed its direction.

There’s no mistaking that most of the tension comes from Clark, quite naturally.  After all, in this scenario Diana gets exactly what she wanted (though she later protests she “didn’t want it to be out of our control”) while Clark faces greater pressure than ever to reassure his fellow man that what he’s doing is nothing to worry about.  There lies the core of Clark and Diana’s conflict, one that many couples likely relate to: he cares too much about what others think; she cares too little.

As you can see, Soule’s handling the progression of this relationship quite smartly, but he’s reluctant to drive the couple toward confrontation or even discussion that will give them useful answers.  Clark and Diana’s opening conversation about the public reaction to Them hits all the relevant points, but without carrying their train of thought to its destination.  As it so often happens in this series, the urgency of the plot interferes with any real relationship building.

But to be honest, most of the title’s interest does lie away from the couple themselves.  More often than not, you find yourself wanting to see more of Diana and Hessia’s life away from Themyscira or Clark’s early relationship with Zod.  Like many sadistic individuals, Zod can be very charming when he wants to be, and at certain points of his interaction with Clark, you wish their enmity could be avoided, or at least delayed.  It’s kind of fun to experience Zod’s somewhat pervy machismo (“I would know more of [Diana].  You did well there, Kal-El!  Fiery.  Beautiful.  Nothing like a strong woman.”) and his familiarity of Clark’s alien lineage (“Your father liked them strong, too.”).  Too bad Soule has Zod cut to the chase with military precision and speed, as it denies him the opportunity to show some personality beyond the ruthless egomaniac.

It’s also perplexing that Soule would truncate this once-in-a-lifetime period of Zod and Clark’s relationship, yet spend a sizable chunk exploring the dynamic between Clark and Cat Grant (and her rich, good-natured boyfriend Aaron).  Not that there’s anything corny or awkward about their exchanges—quite the opposite—but Cat will always be a part of Clark’s life; Zod has only one chance to be on friendly terms with his enemy’s son.  Like I said, though, Soule’s ear for voicing makes both Cat and Aaron seem like believable foils to the reserved Clark.  Both Cat’s winsomeness and flaws are on full display and evenly balanced.  Unlike traditional portrayals of her as a careless bimbo, this Cat is exuberant, genuinely affectionate, even logical; she merely suffers from the all-too-common vice of avoiding extra trouble if it doesn’t benefit her directly.

A final point in response to commenter David Austin, who recently observed a certain dichotomy between Diana as she appears in her own ongoing and the one we get here.  It’s true these are two significantly different portrayals, but I’m not sure that makes Soule’s take inferior.  If anything, Soule’s Diana is even more human, emotionally honest, and true to her character, recognizing why someone like her would be interested in pursuing a relationship with the conservative Clark (“[S]omeday our battles will end.  And there would be no greater tragedy…than facing that end alone.”) and delivering a speech to a bunch of little girls that perfectly encapsulates her feminist perspective in the gentlest way possible.

I don’t quite understand why Soule felt the need to split this issue into two parts, given how integrated each is with the other, except to avoid interrupting Daniel’s supermodel, bombastic art from Paulo Siqueira’s more generic (though quite nearly as attractive) figures.  This seems to suit Soule’s purposes fine; Daniel proves surprisingly nuanced at capturing the sober, dramatic tone of the issue’s first half, while Siqueira ably brings out the personality of the characters in their civilian lives.  To equalize things even further, Morey and Hi-Fi deliver the same bright, vivacious, glossy colors to their respective pencillers.

Conclusion: You definitely get a sense that the issue falls just short of its potential, a result of odd storytelling choices and points that don’t quite make it to completion.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – So it seems pretty much agreed upon by most writers that Hal’s kind of a douche in the new DCU.  See him complaining about Superman’s lack of respect for the dibs he had on Diana, and see Barry’s perfectly disgusted response: “Hal, respect’s probably why she’s dating him in the first place.  Dibs…please.”  As Kelso of That ‘70s Show would say: Burn!

– My favorite response to the Superman-Wonder Woman coupling is an exchange between two guys examining a picture of the couple kissing. “Jealous.”

“Of who?”

“…Either, really.”  Sounds about right, actually.

Grade

Conclusion