![]()
By: Kyle Higgins (writer), Will Conrad & Cliff Richards (art), Pete Pantazis (colors)
The Story: Nightwing juggles a manic mimic, a tea-crazed hatter, and a micro-managing roommate as life in Chicago continues.
The Review: One of the prime problems of Nightwing’s character is that he’s not Batman. Batman is the best and Nightwing is not him. Q.E.D Nightwing is not the best. Now many of us know better, but defining what qualities make Nightwing more than Batman-lite shows us another problem. Batman is driven, simple, and universally likable from the safe distance of readership. You don’t need to give Batman relatable problems, you just need him to be grizzled and spout a great one-liner now and again and that saves pages. The sane among us may champion the supreme interpersonal skills that make Nightwing the core of the DCU, but it’s actually his strengths that have often caused him to struggle.
Consider Nightwing #27, for instance. This is a terrible Batman story. Sure, it would be easy enough to replace Marionette with Catwoman and return the Mad Hatter to Gotham City, but the stakes are nowhere near high enough. One cop, one friend, and a hot thief? Batman saves that many people over breakfast! A Batman story like that could never survive in a world of “The Court of Owls” or “Death of the Family”s, but Nightwing? Nightwing could pull it off, if handled right. Enter Kyle Higgins, who continues to demonstrate that he understands Dick Grayson at least as well as he does Nightwing.
Part of what makes Higgins’ Nightwing so true to the character is how clearly you can hear both Batman and Robin rattling around in his head. One minor artistic misstep from Will Conrad on the opening page combines with Higgins’ writing to show us something that looks and sounds a lot like a Robin-era Dick in the Nightwing suit. From there Higgins adds some playful flirtation, a touch of self-deprecation, and a dash of honest-to-goodness nerdiness to positively nail Dick Grayson’s voice, and all in the first six pages.
From there, he introduces two quiet mysteries and the clues needed to solve them while wrapping up ongoing plots for each of Dick’s roommates. We also see the end of this Mad Hatter plotline and hints of things yet to come from a recent addition to the series. If that sounds like a busy issue, you’re absolutely right. The cuts have to come somewhere and, in this instance, Higgins chooses to deemphasize the superheroing a little. You’ll still get your fix, but I can’t say that the Hatter pushes Nightwing to his limits this issue.
Despite this, you’ll get plenty of closure from Dick Grayson’s adventures. There isn’t even much of an overarching theme, as Higgins jumps from one idea to the next, eschewing much of modern trade-based comic thinking in favor of a more slice-of-life feel. Still, there’s no bigger hero moment in the issue than Dick’s reconciliation with Joey. It’s touching and smart and wonderful. If there’s a lesson to take from Nightwing #27 it’s that a hug can accomplish more than all the flips and kicks in the world and that’s a moral I can get behind.
From the very first page, Will Conrad seems to be having a great deal of fun with his layouts. Indeed, while the quality of artwork is fairly comparable to last month’s chapter, there is a marked improvement in regard to panel arrangements. Pages are saturated with the same coiled-spring energy that Higgins and Conrad bring to their protagonist. And while things can get rather busy, Conrad manages to hold back enough to keep things easy to read. Even the most complicated compositions should be easy to follow for veteran, new, and spatially-challenged readers alike.
Conrad also gives Marionette some special attention, making her one of the most interesting characters to watch throughout the issue. Unfortunately, Conrad’s style almost inevitably leads to some wonky facial expressions. It’s not terrible; there’s definitely more good than bad, but it is a minor blemish on the issue. Perhaps the only character to escape unscathed is Jen, who looks great throughout the issue. It’s a rare but happy day when a story’s sole teenage girl is the most consistently drawn.
Cliff Richards stops in to do some fill-in work at the end of the book, with mixed results. Though Richards’ work is technically proficient it can’t stand up to Conrad’s this month. Both artists share a fairly realistic style and a care in their shading, Richards’ characters feel stretched and weary. Seriously, Dick looks like he’s on tranquilizers for pretty much all of the issue’s last three pages.
One thing that Richards nails is the dramatic importance of Dick and Joey’s talk. The whole scene makes excellent use of his talent for blocking and really supports the sense that their friendship had been truly strained.
The Conclusion: Conrad and Richards innovate in elements of composition as Kyle Higgins tells a tale that’s as much Dick Grayson’s as it is Nightwing’s. Though it won’t sate the hunger for explosions or complex fight scenes, Kyle Higgins supplies another excellent Dick Grayson adventure in the back-heavy second half of his Mad Hatter story. I’ll be sad when this era of Nightwing ends.
Grade: B
– Noah Sharma
Grade
Conclusion