By: Keith Giffen & J.M. DeMatteis (story), Howard Porter (art), Hi-Fi (colors)

The Story: The League faces its greatest enemy to date: a young woman with raging hormones.

The Review: As common as it’s become to open a story in the middle of the action, in monthly comics, this kind of narrative device tends to be more counterproductive than anything else.  Starting the reader off with only a minimum of context is a risky business; you better hope your characters or ongoing action are strong enough to keep the reader interested, or else they won’t wait around to have things explained to them.

With that in mind, Justice League 3000 definitely started off on the wrong foot by introducing us to our heroes at their least likable stage and repeatedly making excuses for them from there.  Most of the time, those excuses are as harmful to the characters as rehabilitating, as Teri discovers the hard way when she exasperatedly calls the new League “brain-damaged children” without realizing she’s still on an open channel with the team.  Repeatedly mentioning that this League is sub-par to its former incarnation may explain the members’ eccentricities, but it also reminds us that this is a sub-par League.

It would help if there was something like humor, good or not, beneath all the squabbling.  You’d think Giffen, mastermind of the original Justice League International, Super Buddies, and other amusingly incompatible groups of superheroes, would have no problem accomplishing such a feat, yet the issue is devoid of even the lightest chuckle.  To be fair, he’s working with a decidedly unfunny cast of characters here.  It’s not as if the League is famous for bringing the funny, even at the best of times.  It’s easy enough to get laughs if you have Booster Gold and Blue Beetle doing the buddy-idiot thing, or Guy Gardner sexually harassing every female within a one-panel radius.  Having Superman repeat his lame catchphrase, “Don’t call me Clark,”* is not going to cut it.

There is almost only one moment in the entire issue where this facsimile of a League feels even remotely normal, and that is Barry Allen expressing his anxiety about the Five’s power levels to Diana, calling them “demigods.”  In a surprising moment of clarity, she reassures him, “Paradoxical as it sounds, Flash—even the gods are human.  There’s nothing to be afraid of.”  It’s proof, however scant, that these characters are capable of shedding the worst parts of their personalities.  The question is whether you can stand them long enough to see it happen.

The answer is probably not.  Giffen-DeMatteis strive to make the Five into compelling antagonists, amping up their power levels and oddities to even greater extremes than the League.  But if Locus is an indicator of her teammates, the Five is disproportionately powerful to their integrity as characters.  Locus is basically a sadistic bimbo whose abilities to warp reality are exactly the kind of thing the League’s power sets are usually not cut out for.  If victory is to be eked at some point, they will have to, funnily enough, take advantage of her personality defects, even as they struggle with their own.

Porter’s art is full of energy, but it’s also chaotic and sloppy, his figures tending to blend together (especially with Hi-Fi’s heavy, painted colors) instead of standing apart.  There’s really nothing subtle about Porter; facial expressions are always a few emotional notches higher than they need to be, and body language is, if anything, even worse.  If the writing on this title seems utterly juvenile, Porter is certainly not helping things with art that looks more fit for the Teen Titans than the Justice League.

Conclusion: Issues like this only serve to convince you that the League is better off as dead legacy heroes in the 31st Century.

Grade: C-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * You may not know this, but this was Leslie Nielsen’s big line in the original script of Airplane! before the writers changed it to “And don’t call me Shirley.”  True story.

– And of course Locus decides, as so many villains do to their detriment, not to finish off the League when she has the chance and instead keep them alive to prolong their suffering.  Rookie mistake.

Grade

Conclusion