![]()
By: Amanda Conner & Jimmy Palmiotti (story), Chad Hardin & Stephane Roux (art), Alex Sinclair (colors)
The Story: Harley makes it clear that pet control will not be part of her landlady duties.
The Review: Does anyone remember Animaniacs? Much as I didn’t care for Yakko, Wakko, and Dot, I loved pretty much every other segment and character on that show, and one of my favorites was “Good Idea, Bad Idea,” a recurring sketch that envisioned the hapless Mr. Skull carrying out the various good ideas (“Drinking fresh milk from the carton.”) and bad ideas (“Drinking fresh milk from the cow.”). It was a weekly lesson on the value of execution.
I bring this up because Harley Quinn can really stand to take that lesson a little more to heart. While almost everything that happens in this issue may have started out as a good idea in Conner-Palmiotti’s head, what ends up on the page is almost invariably a bad idea. Let’s start with an easy one: Bernie, Harley’s charbroiled beaver. Besides just being weird for no other reason than to be weird—and maybe to get the juvenile pleasure of having Harley talk about her beaver all the time—Bernie also has confusing implications for Harley’s mental stability. Most writers see the source of her crimes as coming from a highly skewed perspective on life, not unlike her mentor and soulmate. Talking to Bernie places her squarely into Crazytown.
It’s also hard to tell why Conner-Palmiotti thought there’d be a long-term purpose for Bernie. As comic relief, he’s painfully limited (“Oh, baby, I’d like to gnaw on your twigs!”), and as a confidante, he’s redundant. Conner-Palmiotti are doing a fairly good job whipping up an interesting supporting cast around Harley from scratch, and once they’re set in place, Harley will have less opportunity and need for Bernie. Madame Macabre and Big Tony may not lack the inherent hilarity of a talking dead beaver, but at least they can physically interact with Harley
Another good idea gone wrong: Harley’s mission to free all the pets at her local shelter who are up on the chopping block. In almost any other circumstance, this would be a fun, appropriate misadventure for Harley, but here it just seems too much like a repeat of her pity-rescue of a dachshund just last issue. Even her watery saucer-eyes at the prospect of all those animals getting put down seems like a lower-key version of the reaction she had to seeing the one dog being mistreated.
Conner-Palmiotti try to spice up the unmemorable story with a guest appearance by Poison Ivy, but the timing seems off for a semi-Gotham City Sirens reunion. With Ivy and Harley’s friendship yet to be established in the new DCU,* it feels a bit premature to portray them like criminal Sex in the City wannabes, with Ivy uncharacteristically enthusiastic about having a “girls’ night out,” the only thing she loves better than plants. With Ivy’s personality so altered, and without Catwoman’s balancing presence, the chemistry feels loud and forced, like watching an episode of Three’s Company with only Janet and Chrissy.
Despite these missteps, Hardin (with Roux providing almost indistinguishable assistance here) continues to prove that Harley made the right choice of artist for her own series. Hardin’s pliable style of linework transitions easily from big comical moments to more credible scenes, and with Sinclair’s lush, shimmering colors, often looks like a far more important title than it really is. Hardin’s not all about looks, though; take a gander at the office of the head of the animal shelter and notice the hunting trophies around her. More often than not, the humor of the issue comes from Hardin’s playfulness more than anything in the script.
Conclusion: You could do worse with your time than to read this issue, but it’s definitely not DC’s breakout comedy of the year
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * To my knowledge, anyway. If you can point to any new 52 issue before this depicting their meeting, I’d appreciate it.
– I get that Harley has no qualms about killing, but the more she does it, no matter how deservedly, the harder it is to see past the homicides to her bubbly personality.
Grade
Conclusion