By: Brian Azzarello (story), Cliff Chiang (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: Diana’s not the first person to leave a home visit in tears.

The Review: About a month ago, I had a friendly debate with some buddies about the relative merits of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings.  At first, I couldn’t help being a little stunned that they preferred the comically adventurous Hobbit over the epic saga of LOTR.  As we talked on, however, I realized it’s those very same qualities that makes Hobbit easier to take in and enjoy, while LOTR turns people off with its obsession of building its mythology.

I was reminded of all this reading the latest chapter of Wonder Woman because Azzarello has gotten the title into the same kind of trouble as LOTR.  There’s no doubt he’s succeeded in making the series different from any Wonder Woman series before it, especially in his vision for the Olympians and how their mythological traditions intersect with her superhero roots.  This is not unlike how J.R.R. Tolkien took Arthurian legend and updated it within the contemporary fantasy genre.  The big difference is Tolkien laid out clear paths for his characters to tread, and to date, our starring heroine has mostly stumbled from plot to plot like signposts in the dark.

It’s thus unsurprising to find Diana back on Paradise Island for reasons unexplained—to tie in with her declaration to visit her homeland in Superman/Wonder Woman #4, perhaps?—and then departing shortly afterward without accomplishing anything other than a good cry.  But maybe that was the entire purpose of her brief visit.  Everywhere else, she must hold herself as the ideal, stoic Amazon; she can only freely show her vulnerability on an island populated only by the cold-blooded.  That’s a bit of tragedy that gives her character some color.

But I’m grasping at straws here.  As much as Azzarello would like us to empathize with Diana’s grief, he doesn’t do nearly enough work to sell it.  Her relationships with the supporting cast, for example, feel perfunctory at best, which makes any strong emotional reaction from her to their loss—whether the frozen Hippolyta or the vanished Zola—seem out of proportion to the actual bond she has with those characters.

Even Hera has a more genuine connection to Zola than Diana does, making the mascara-streaking tears on her face more believable than any concern Diana expresses over Zola’s A.W.O.L.  But then, Diana sweats to achieve even close to the same level of personal complexity as the former goddess, who’s tormented by the uncertainty of her newfound mortality: “I feel so lonely, so afraid I’m going to die that way…and I don’t know whom to pray to about making that stop.”  If turning Hera human has humanized her this much, perhaps Diana’s current divinity bodes ill for her future relatability.*

Yet even the other Olympians have more interest going for than Diana.  Apollo’s tortures of the First Born notwithstanding, he, too, reveals a sensitive side in his ill-timed attempt to sympathize with his eldest brother (“[Y]ou’re not alone in suffering the slights of Zeus.”).  Apollo’s twin sister is no less complicated, able to set aside her dislike for Diana to fulfill her rival’s request, just because the challenge to her skills amuses her.  And then there’s Dionysus, whose fun-loving decadence has lately revealed a twisted streak beyond even those of his other relatives.  That’s really the sad part about the current Wonder Woman: there’s some wonderfully intriguing development, but focused everywhere else except where it’s really necessary.

What is it about Chiang’s art that gets you so excited when you see his name on primary drawing credits?  At first glance, the flat figures don’t stand out for any particular reason, but as you look closer, you can’t help marveling at Chiang’s versatility.  Facial expressions are surprisingly nuanced; characters carry their personalities just in their appearance and bearing; and even the rare action sequences have a strong, if extremely short-lived, intensity about them.  Equally as eloquent as Chiang’s lines are Wilson’s colors, which manage to evoke powerful moods even within a restricted range of flat hues.

Conclusion: Chiang’s art and Azzarello’s technique raise the quality level of the issue, but it’s still noticeably bereft of tight plotting and, more importantly, a truly compelling heroine.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * And can you believe “relatability” is not a word when “relatable” is?  I intend to change that and I’m starting now!

– Cassandra dresses her Minotaur in BDSM gear.  How racy of her.

Grade

Conclusion