By: Kevin Eastman, Bobby Curnow, Tom Waltz (story), Ross Campbell (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)

The Story: Nothing like a good campfire to bring mutants together.

The Review: I would never have expected TMNT to become one of the longest-lived titles on my pull list, but at 25 issues and counting, it’s getting up there.  It just proves that pretty much anything can be the basis of a consistently entertaining story as long as you have decent creators treating it right.  Working together, Eastman-Curnow-Waltz have given layers to a series that’s basically about anthropomorphized turtles learning the secrets of martial arts.

But TMNT is about so much more than that.  Above all other things, the series is about family, relating to each other despite extreme differences in personalities, appearances, and species.  More than caring about each individual member of the Turtle cast, you place a lot of investment in the relationships among them, which have been endangered by events in the most recent batch of issues.  Although the nature of TMNT leaves you in little doubt that things will be all right in the end, that doesn’t stop you from sympathizing with the pain Splinter, Donnie, Mikey, and Raphael feel as Leo keeps them at a distance.

Thankfully, the gap between them closes significantly by the end of this issue, thanks largely to the vision of Shen, wife and mother to the Turtle family.  While I’m not thrilled with her ability to sweep away big emotional problems with some dreamy After School Special speeches, giving her a more prominent spiritual position in the series is a smart move.  Since she apparently didn’t merit a second life as a mutant animal like the rest of her family, allowing her to commune with them when they most need her emotional support keeps her important to the story, but not for purely sentimental reasons.

Anyway, Shen only clears the path for her family to reunite, leaving them to cross it themselves.  As cheesy as the kumbaya moment is when Mikey starts roasting hot dogs over a campfire and the smell brings everyone (minus April and Casey), even Apolex, together, it’s also true to Mikey’s simple, pure-hearted nature and it is, as Shen says, a small step forward.  The hugs aren’t flying around yet, which is good, from a fictional perspective.  I expect that big rifts in the Turtle family are rare events, so Eastman-Curnow-Waltz should mine the dramatic potential of this one before they inevitably wrap it up.

Meanwhile, they’re smart enough not to let the gears on the overarching plotlines stop completely as they focus on domestic troubles.  The revelation that April’s parents have their own ties to Stockgen and Ooze is a bit fortuitous, but it also gives April an opportunity to move the story forward herself instead of just getting swept up in it.  Donnie also reminds us that the threat of the Technodrome is still out there and must be dealt with.  And the final page reveal of yet another mutant warrior on Karai’s payroll makes it clear that just because the Turtles managed to escape the Foot doesn’t mean the clan is going to become any less of a problem in the near future.  There’s no shortage of adversaries to tackle after this; the only question is which one our heroes should deal with first.

This is not against Campbell’s general style at all—the man clearly knows how to draw and he does it very well—but sometimes his art is just too cute for words.  Maybe it’s all that roundedness in his linework, those really strong, circular curves which makes almost any animal character look adorable.  But there are worse things in the world than comic book art that happens to resemble a kiddie cartoon, and Campbell clearly knows how to ramp up the intensity when the scene calls for it.  That is one serious murder face Leo has on as he slashes his way through a nightmare of Shredder.

Conclusion: A great blend of plot and character developments, of pathos and heart.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – As sweet as Shen’s tender caresses of Splinter are, you can’t help feeling a bit creeped out by the sight of a beautiful woman embracing a big-ass rat.

Grade

Conclusion