
By: Charles Soule (story), Javier Pulido (art), Muntsa Vicente (colors)
The Story: There’s only one way to hurt She-Hulk. A bad performance review.
The Review: In the interest of exposing possible bias, I should tell you that I had a lot of reasons to be excited for this series. First, it’s one of those rare female-led titles. Second, the female in question has an actual job. Third, the job in question is lawyering, which appeals to someone still struggling through law school (i.e., me). Finally, we’ve got a superb creative team featuring three individuals who have all made it on my Favorite Things lists of the past two years.*
So maybe I’m just geeking out when I say that from the get-go, Soule gets She-Hulk exactly right. In a single page, he sums up everything marvelous and exciting about She-Hulk as a superhero: her power (ripping apart giant war-vehicles with ease), her boldness (drinking games with fellow booze-bags Thor and Tony Stark), and her sensitivity (crouching down to shake hands with a fan about a tenth her size). The very next page, we see Jennifer Walters in business wear, reclined in her shared office at Paine & Luckberg, LLP, the firm where she works as one of its brightest associates. “This is also the She-Hulk,” Soule reminds us.
The rest of the issue is dedicated to exploring this other side of the green giantess, and it’s easily as appealing as the side that takes electrical blasts like a bad static shock. Most of her appeal, practically all of it, is in Jenn’s utterly justified confidence. She’s unconcerned about her performance review not because of her feats in the Fantastic Four, but because of her dedication as a fantastic lawyer. It’s her employers who want to shoehorn her into her costume, reducing her occupation to a mere shadow of her costume.
Obviously, Jenn refuses to be so entrapped, leading her to first case as a solo attorney. On the surface, it’s about the widow of a criminal inventor whose ideas got poached by one of Tony Stark’s more unsavory subsidiaries—which would be juicy enough as an opening story. But the issue is really about making a case for how entertaining a superhero book can be even when the superheroing is kept to a few panels of robot-bashing. By the end of the issue, Jenn has won that case as handily as the one she takes on for the poor Mrs. Harrow, though it requires a couple incredibly fortuitous plot devices to get there.
This achievement is a testament to Soule as both a writer and lawyer. In a field where legal references are usually minimal (and incorrect), Soule distinguishes himself by tackling all kinds of legal concepts, backed by clear firsthand experience. In Jenn’s frustrating dealings with Tony’s top attorney, Soule exposes the ruthless complications of the U.S. legal system, designed to streamline and relieve the courts, but abused to delay and crush lawsuits. As Tony’s legal man puts it, “I am neither bad nor good. I am simply legal.” Against such a system, Jenn stands out as a hero among lawyers, declaring what should be the guiding principle of all good attorneys: “I’m not going to take the case because I don’t think you’ll end up in court at all. Ninety percent of lawyering is conversations.”
I warned you, DC, to find an ongoing for Pulido before it’s too late, and now I’m afraid the “too late” mark has passed. It’s true that Pulido doesn’t have the lushest, or most detailed style, but his style has an even more prized quality: recognizability. Although his linework has an even gutsier, broader, slightly angular look than contemporaries like Chris Samnee or Cliff Chiang, his lines are just as clean and palatable. There’s also more innate comedy in Pulido’s work, which fits She-Hulk’s good-humored tone very, very well. Vicente’s bold Private Eye colors are applied equally well to the boldness of She-Hulk, making Pulido’s retro style look hip and modern.
Conclusion: An appropriately strong first outing that embodies all of the title’s appeal and creative power, even if the plot resolves itself a bit too conveniently.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Pulido was on my Favorite Things of 2012. Both Soule and Vicente were on my Favorite Things of 2013—which appeared briefly on this site in early January and was soon thereafter removed for editorial reasons.
– You know it’s a bad day for a judge when an attorney moves to strike his joke from the record.
– Oooh. The P&L partners asks Jenn to take “the blue file” with her when she quits the firm. Don’t you just love how naming anything “the [blank] file” gives it instant import and ominousness?
Grade
Conclusion