![]()
By: Rob Williams (story), Simon Coleby (art), JD Mettler (colors)
The Story: A war among the world’s superpowers—literally.
The Review: I don’t mind telling you that the Vertigo revival has been something of a mixed bag so far—which shouldn’t be all that shocking, frankly, given the success rate of fiction in general. If I’m experiencing an unusual amount of disappointment, that’s probably because I had been hoping Vertigo would finally unleash a flood of creative daring that it had secretly kept back for some years. What we’ve gotten instead has been interesting, but not incredible.
If I had to put my finger on the problem, it’s the lack of conceptual novelty. Not to suggest that an indie title has to have a gimmick to stand out, but look, if you’re not bringing new ideas to the table, then the execution has to be that much greater to keep people invested. A title like Hinterkind, for example, can’t separate itself from the pack when it relies so heavily on the tropes of its genre(s). Compare it to Royals, which immediately distinguishes itself with a rather clever premise: how would history turn if the world’s royalty had more than purely ceremonial or political power. It’s just a great idea, perfectly fitted for comics.
It also opens up a lot of questions for how this kind of world came to be. Once upon a time, people believed their royalty got to be where they were by divine providence. Was that theory literalized in Royals? Or is there a more socio-scientific explanation? Perhaps the ones with powers simply took advantage of them to assert their authority and they’ve been holding on to it (via interbreeding) ever since.
Either way, it seems like history has stubbornly held its course in this series; neither the French nor Bolshevik Revolutions left their respective royal families unscathed, apparently, which means despite their powers, the Royals are not invincible. But that’s actually an even more troubling notion. It means they have a strong interest in appeasing their citizens, which also means their powers may be used in service of the ever-changing needs of the general public.
We can see the danger of such a situation when the well-meaning Prince Henry, sickened by the daily German bombings of London circa WWII, impulsively joins the fray. This might relieve his conscience and please the suffering population, but it also frees the other Royals to participate, and you can be sure WWII won’t be the same for it. Under these circumstances, the seeming indifference of the Royals may actually have been preferable to activeness. Their presence turns an international conflict into a series of individual power struggles, in which entire nations of people are mere sidekicks. Hence we have a doomed British bombing raid in the issue’s opening, all just to give Henry a chance to spar with a German Royal. This series demands to know how far the great power and great responsibility theorem should stretch.
In terms of character work, Henry is at least a respectable protagonist, if not exactly a likable one, and you’re content to see him grapple with all the moral dilemmas his abilities lead him to. The other cast members are about as well-developed as Henry, which is to say not very much. Arthur and Rose neatly fall into the Irresponsible Brother and Supportive Sister archetypes, and beyond that display little personality at all. Perhaps their brother’s leap into action will inspire them to reveal more of themselves, but I doubt you’ll end up loving them in a six-issue mini.
Coleby has a style that calls to mind the photorealism of Ben Oliver, though less stiff and with a bit more detail, perhaps. What both artists have in common is a habit of filling panels with looming figures, sparing them the trouble of fleshing out settings. It makes for a very straightforward read, but a rather dull one. Coleby only gives you what the script demands, and makes little effort to do any world-building beyond that minimum. It has a very limited budget look, to tell the truth.
Conclusion: Williams takes an intriguing “What if…?” question and plays it out well, although it could use some more textual and visual flair.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Now you see why the DC writers had to come up with Hitler using the Spear of Destiny to keep America’s superheroes out of the European theater in WWII. A corny concept to solve a rather complex logistical problem.
Grade
Conclusion