![]()
By: Keith Giffen & J.M. DeMatteis (story), Howard Porter (art), Hi-Fi (colors)
The Story: Earth has finally become the disgusting cesspool we all thought it would.
The Review: After reading this issue, I’ve cobbled up a theory about how Giffen-DeMatteis are handling this series. I don’t think they care much for the idea of a cloned Justice League in the 31st Century and either they’re putting in a minimum of effort into the story or they’re deliberately trying to sabotage it. Otherwise, I can’t explain why Giffen-DeMatteis would seemingly go out of their way to make everything in this series as unpleasant as possible.
Out of respect for Giffen-DeMatteis’ chosen premise, I could stand a thoroughly unlikable League for a short while, so long as there was a payoff at the end of it, or if Giffen-DeMatteis would reveal some redeeming qualities to our supposed heroes. Instead, the more time we spend with the League, the less appealing they become. In that sense, it was a mistake to have an issue focused on the Trinity, who have been the most problematic members of the cast thus far. Trapping them together without the buffers of Hal or Barry could only expose more of their worst personality traits.
For example, in addition to being an arrogant prick, Superman’s also something of a lecher (“Admit it, babe: every time I touch you a little chill runs through your—”). Fantastic. It also appears that Wonder Woman’s moral compass has shrunk considerably, as in response to a thug’s threat to mow down an entire plaza of innocent people, she replies, “And…?” Perhaps this has something to do with the difficulties of replicating a Kryptonian and Amazon; it would explain why Flash, Green Lantern, and Batman most resemble their past selves.
With my patience worn this thin with our primary protagonists, it’s no wonder that my reaction to Terry and Teri’s umpteenth argument over the League is something along the lines of, Oh, my word, kill me now. I find it impossible to believe that Giffen-DeMatteis can be oblivious to how annoyingly repetitive these scenes are. They’d have done better by the issue by leaving the pages blank; the scenes would have been equally as unproductive, but they would have grated less on your nerves. It’s a sign of how weary I am of this title that I found myself appalled by what would have otherwise been an innocuous scene: after watching the League shredded, devoured, and teleported to locations unknown, Terry and Teri work out their frustrations by literally working out. This seems bizarrely callous, not to mention random, considering the situation at hand.
In trying to scrape together anything in the issue that gives you hope that things would get better, I only found a smidgeon of credibility in Ariel Masters, one of the co-masterminds behind the cloned League. She’s about the only character who has some balance in her personality—snappish, but with an appreciable degree of humor and sense—not to mention some clear morals. But is Ariel really the person you want to invest in? Can her inoffensiveness make up for the serious defects in all the other characters in this series? I think not.
Such a problematic script could really use an outstanding artist to smooth out its rough edges and give you something pretty to look at as you endure the painful words. But Porter simply can’t fulfill that tall order with his rather unappealing style. He can draw details to beat the band, admittedly, sometimes even to the point of distraction, but in almost all other respects, his figures just look like they belong in a lower-tier book. The pointed, pouty features in the characters seem particularly suited for something like Teen Titans, or any other title you don’t plan to take seriously.
Conclusion: Perhaps this is just the darkness before the dawn, but you have no confidence that the dawn to come will offer anything other than a waning glimmer of light. Dropped—and unceremoniously, I might add.
Grade: D+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Just to prove what little sensitivity Locus has, Giffen-DeMatteis have her reveal that after shrinking Hal, she “expelled [him] in a kinda/sorta unpleasant way.” I don’t understand why Hal won’t just admit he loves her; she’s adorable!
Grade
Conclusion