By: Geoff Johns (story), Ivan Reis (layouts), Joe Prado & Scott Hanna (finishes), Rod Reis (colors)

The Story: These robots have awakened with a singular purpose: watching wrestling on TV.

The Review: Much as I love old-timey, slightly odd comic book characters, I sometimes think the Metal Men are a concept that, like the Doom Patrol, Sea Devils, or Challengers of the Unknown, seem like they’re best left in the Silver Age.  These concepts almost pull the complete hat trick for failure, in some respects too simplistic and silly for the sophisticates, in others too weird and niche for a popular audience.

In these cases, the only writer I trust to revive these characters and preserve their appeal for another generation is Johns.  Whatever critiques I have of his particular writing style, there is no one who has a better success rate at updating properties long thought obsolete.  So it goes with the Metal Men.  Johns tackles them with such genuine enthusiasm and heart that they feel fresh and enticing again, without compromising what made them popular in the first place.

Johns isn’t reinventing the wheel here.  The Metal Men are still a rambunctious gang of robots with diverse, some might say loud personalities, introduced with that oh-so-Johnsian directness: Gold’s narcissism (“—online and looking good.  Damn good.”); Tin’s insecurity (“I figured I’d make a pretty g-good wastebasket if nothing else.”); Iron’s bravado (“You get pay-per-view down here?  WCW is on in five.”); Mercury’s temper (“A command?  What do you think I am?  A dog?”); and Platinum’s romantic obsessiveness (“…I think [the lab is] cute.  Whoa.  And so are you.”).  It’s as cheesy as it sounds, but fun and credible, coming from robots.

The interaction among the Metal Men is enjoyable enough, but it’s how they operate around Will Magnus that really sells.  I don’t know much about past incarnations of Magnus, but Johns has an interesting take on him here: the young genius, embittered by human behavior, yet forced to confront it in spades from his own creations, much to his dismay.  This leaves Magnus no longer on the periphery of the story, as he often is in Metal Men adventures.  In fact, you could say this issue is really about Magnus finding his humanity, set amid a Metal Men origin story.  The Men were designed and programmed to be heroes; it’s Magnus who evolves into one.

Although Magnus ends up with the more important character arc in this issue, that doesn’t mean Johns plans to leave them as the comical sidekicks spinning around their long-suffering master.  The fact that they spontaneously develop feelings despite Magnus’ best intentions is even more reason to eventually pit them against Grid, a creature aiming to achieve the same feat.  At any rate, it seems like they’ll have a much bigger role in the DCU than the Sea Devils, whom Johns revived for a bit part in Aquaman and has done nothing with since.

One thing’s for sure: the Metal Men have never looked as good as they do here.  Reis is one of the perfect mainstream artists because he balances all the superhero elements (action, drama, comedy) so well, all within that wonderfully lush and attractive linework.  I should also point out that Reis has the ability to draw average-looking characters without making them completely non-descript.  As someone with a fairly gooey frame himself, I appreciate that Magnus is on the skinny, unmuscled, everyman side.

Conclusion: With a fresh vision courtesy of Johns and Reis, the new Metal Men are not merely throwbacks to the past, but endearing in a way that only classic DC characters can be.

Grade: B+

-Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Is it wrong that I really want to see how Lead’s love affair with the soda machine plays out?

– Question: how did the Metal Men’s responsometers survive their encounter with Chemo when their metallic bodies did not?

Grade

Conclusion