![]()
By: Amanda Conner & Jimmy Palmiotti (story), Chad Hardin (art), Alex Sinclair (colors)
The Story: It’s a bad day when a long-haired dwarf turns down a date with you.
The Review: I tried watching Dexter some years ago, back when it was new and getting wildly popular, despite all the controversy it generated. I was enthralled by the first few episodes as much as anyone else, but at some point, I suddenly felt like I could no longer stomach the idea of getting entertainment out of murder. It was less a moral reaction than a biological one; every time Dexter took out one of those microscope slides, I started getting slightly queasy.
There’s something like that going on here with Harley Quinn. I don’t know about anyone else, but I’m getting less and less mileage out of the macabre humor of this title with every passing month. Again, it’s not so much the immorality of Harley’s kills that disturbs me, although that does play a part. I’m fine with her bumping off anyone who goes after her first, but brutally slaying anyone, even prison inmates, for actions they can’t help is a lot less justifiable.
You might say gratuitous violence isn’t a surprising hazard of a series starring a villain, and you’d be right, but wouldn’t you agree that there should be a point to the violence? In Harley Quinn, Conner-Palmiotti use violence for its comedic value, and there is something like a Quentin Tarantino-ish camp to the issue, but the overall sensibility feels more along the lines of Judd Apatow’s gross-out humor: watching one prison escapee slipping, banana peel style, on one of his compatriots’ severed arms, for example.
Anyway, the comedy in this issue is pretty grisly even without the blood and gore. I have never found Palmiotti all that funny as a writer, and even with Conner’s assistance, his jokes rarely aim higher than the pun-tastic: “Check out my dweeb-whacker,” “Now it’s my turn to be a propane in your ass,” “You can have a piece’a my sweet axe,” that kind of thing. It gets pretty bad—and I should know, being something of a punny guy myself. See what I did there?
But these are the ongoing problems of this title; the issue itself almost completely falls apart by virtue of its slapstick premise. Ivy leaving behind a plant whose berries, when ingested, cause others to fall in lust with the consumer is yet another variation on the inexplicable magnetism plot, causing all kinds of madcap mischief for Harley. It’s entertaining enough, in an exhausting sort of way, but it doesn’t do anything for her character.
If anything, this Valentine’s-themed issue slightly muddles the way we understand Harley by reducing her to the same unlucky-in-love female that fiction is just rife with these days. Between her love-hate relationship with the holiday and her express desire for “…Someone to worship the very ground I walk on. Unconditional love. Someone committed,” Harley sounds a lot like Meg Ryan at the beginning of a romantic comedy, except there’s no payoff in greater wisdom about love than what she had at the beginning.
If there’s any laughs to be had, it’s going to come from Hardin’s art, which has proven itself equal to the task of any juvenile, cartoonish silliness Conner-Palmiotti can devise. In fact, if you’re inclined to laugh at all in reading the issue, it’s more likely from Hardin’s comical expressions and visual gags than any joke in the script.
Conclusion: With this issue, I’ve hit my limit of Harley Quinn’s murderous antics, not to mention the title’s generally uninspired quality. Dropped.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – And the award for Lamest Comeback of All Time goes to the smooching stranger on the boardwalk. “Get a room,” Harley tells her in disgust. “We’ll get a room when you get a life!” she snaps. Brava.
Grade
Conclusion