By: Kevin Eastman, Bobby Curnow, Tom Waltz (story), Ross Campbell (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)

The Story: How much tai chi does it take to soothe betrayal?

The Review: While I’ve often admired this series for its willingness to provide a more mature read than what would normally be expected from the TMNT, there’s no avoiding the fact that the Turtles are aimed toward a younger crowd of readers.  Specifically, the straightforward plots and conflicts, as well as the willingness to engage in a slightly higher level of violence, seems tailor-made for the adolescent demographic.

Frankly, I think even adolescents won’t have a hard time catching on to TMNT’s more obvious plotlines.  Case in point: the Foot Clan falcon tailing after Apolex (and, consequently, the Turtles).  I’m quite sure almost anyone could have foreseen the tentative trust between Apolex and the Turtles being shattered once the Foot revealed themselves.  That’s exactly how this issue plays out, hitting every predictable beat like clockwork, from Raphael’s outrage to Apolex’s protests of innocence.

If Eastman-Curnow-Waltz were going to crutch so heavily on formula, they could at least have delayed the inevitable a little longer, if for no other reason than to make Apolex’s inclusion in the Turtle family a little smoother.  As is, Raphael’s friendship with her seems a bit too sudden given his earlier antipathy, and none of the others, not even Leo, get an opportunity to interact with her.  You’re not that invested in Apolex’s relationship with the Turtles by the time the Foot strike, meaning you don’t much care one way or another if she’ll regain their acceptance.

The Foot attack also forces Eastman-Curnow-Waltz to speed up Leo’s reconciliation with Splinter.  Much as you appreciate them reconnecting based on their spiritual closeness to Tang Shen, wielding that particular emotional tool at this stage feels a little too blunt.  It’s a bit simplistic to believe that one of Splinter’s classic speeches can so easily bring Leo back to his side in such a short amount of time, no matter how sentimental or wise.

As for things going on with the human cast, April’s new hairdo is of little moment.  Perhaps it’s meant merely to confirm her more active role in the series, but otherwise, your take on it will largely depend on whether you prefer women to wear their hair short or long.  Nearly as sudden and awkward as her slight makeover is an injected conflict on what she should do with a purely healing, non-mutating sample of Ooze.  For one thing, it would’ve been nice to actually see her arrive at this dilemma; for another, it would’ve been to the issue’s dramatic benefit to let her grapple with the question a little longer before she gets blanket approval from Casey to use it on her dad.  Again, it’s a case of the writers rushing through the plotline instead of letting it grow.

One thing about April’s close-shorn hair is that it emphasizes the roundness of her features, which in turn emphasizes Campbell’s ultra-curvy, almost cutesy artwork.  I’ll be the last person to describe his style as unattractive, but I personally find it hard to take the issue seriously, especially at its most sober moments, when the characters are just one height-change away from looking like chibis.  Nevertheless, the man can amp up the intensity to convincingly draw an assassination attempt on the Turtles and their fierce counterattack.  It’s just a cute sort of assassination scene.

Conclusion: Although the issue makes some good developments on several fronts, it doesn’t juggle them as fluidly as previous issues have done.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Raphael does tai chi.  The question is whether it’s really helping.

– Frankly, seeing the Turtles and Apolex eat sandwiches in a group circle is just adorable.

Grade

Conclusion