By: Charles Soule (story), Javier Pulido (art), Muntsa Vicente (colors)

The Story: Jenn makes some potentially brilliant/disastrous hiring decisions.

The Review: In reviewing the debut issue of She-Hulk, Kelly Thompson of Comic Book Resources observed an unbalance between Jennifer Walters, superhero, and Jennifer Walters, esquire, noting it could turn off devotees of traditional superhero books.  Being more of a DC man myself, it’s awkward for me to be in the position of Marvel apologist, but once again, I’m going to respond to this seeming criticism of one of Marvel’s newest titles.

You see, I’m of the mind that the superhero genre already confines itself too much to spandex-clad action sequences, pitting hero versus villain in various scenarios of moral difficulty.  I find nothing wrong with (and even encourage) a superhero title that places more emphasis on the hero than the super.  It certainly shouldn’t be a reason to criticize a series, although it’s a perfectly good reason for certain people to find another series to read.

Anyway, this issue does take us back to some conventional punching of giant robots, although it doesn’t form the spine of the plot by any means.  In fact, the twin A.I.M. goons operating the robots are only a small sentient step up from the automatic defense systems that attacked Jenn last issue.  They’re not important in themselves, nor are they meant to be; they’re only the unlucky targets for She-Hulk and Hellcat’s self-disappointment.

While Jenn’s career struggles may justify a girls’ night out, even a little impromptu vigilantism, things aren’t so bad for her to tell one A.I.M. goon grimly, “I’m a woman whose life seems to fall apart a little more every…single…day.”  Things definitely aren’t bad enough to drive her to beat him to death, just to “give my life a little meaning,” especially since her pal has it so much worse.  In a moment of drunken clarity, Patsy snaps, “[Y]ou have things going on.  I…I don’t have anything.  No guy, no real job.  Every so often I hit things and help save the day.”

That statement also offers a response to any criticism of a superhero title for shortchanging the superheroics, which, at its heart, is about escapism, for both the readers and the characters.  Superheroes often do what they do as much to avoid facing the ugly realities of their personal lives as to mete justice.  Think of Clark Kent flying off from romantic trouble, or Hal Jordan taking a space trek after going broke on Earth, or Patsy challenging giant robots because her last boyfriend kept telling her, “Size isn’t everything.”

Jenn is not the type to fling herself into one part of her life just because another isn’t going well.  “I just want to do the best I can, at everything, while I can,” she says.  With that perfectionist personality, of course her superhero life will take a backslide while she gets her crumbling legal career back up to par.  But with the last page reveal of Kristoff Vernard, son of Victor Von Doom, requesting help to obtain political asylum, Soule reassures us that there can be a happy middle ground between legal drama and traditional superhero.

But Soule brings a lot more to the title than just those two genre trappings.  He brings fun, fresh settings filled with characters that don’t feel as if they’ve just been manufactured from the factory of comic book supporting characters.  Whether it’s Sharon King, an ex-mutant who runs an office building catered to supers, or Angie Huang, a rather dour overachiever who bullies her way into becoming Jenn’s new paralegal (along with her monkey Hei Hei*), Soule clearly puts as much thought as imagination into what he writes.

I can understand why Pulido would be a polarizing artist for this series.  There’s certainly nothing about his art that’s traditionally superheroic, and his simple, polygonic style does limit the range of his expression and intensity to a certain extent.  For all that, his art radiates a very likable personality, made more so by Vicente’s funky colors.  She-Hulk’s not exactly a comedy, but Pulido brings out every moment of humor with deadpan delivery, like Patsy’s disheveled appearance as she tries to outdrink Jenn or the flinty, predator’s gaze in Angie’s eyes.

Conclusion: Not your traditional superhero book, but a very worthy superhero book all the same, perhaps all the more so because of its very lack of tradition.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * In Chinese, “hei” stands for joy or bliss, so “hei hei” is a kind of double blessing, often thrown around at weddings or other special occasions.

– Angie sort of reminds me of a slightly pudgier Aubrey Plaza, especially in her aura of callous indifference.

– I kind of like the idea of Patsy being the messy drama queen (“You never support me!”) to Jenn’s put-together powerhouse.

Grade

Conclusion